Greg's Bite: Apple vs HTC, S3 Patents invalid!
TweetFollow Us on Twitter

Greg's Bite: Apple vs HTC, S3 Patents invalid!

Posted By Greg Mills

Recently it came out that HTC won one in the legal mega-spat with Apple. HTC had just paid $300,000,000 to S3 for five patents, two of which, had been just found to be infringed by Apple in a separate infringement complaint by the US International Trade Commission. Eager to have something to hold over Apple, HTC bought the patents, apparently not knowing they had just been found to be invalid by the US Patent Office in a re-examination of the patents.

See: http://www.macobserver.com/tmo/article/s3_patents_apple_violates_rules_u... While this article mixes legal terms incorrectly, the basic information is sound. The correct term for issued patents that are later found to be "invalid" is not that they are "unpatentable". The term "unpatentable" refers to patents that are applied for, but the patent denied by the Patent Office as the invention is "unpatentable". If an invention is already patented by someone else or is obvious, the invention is unpatentable.

The ruling in favor of HTC, which cleared Apple iOS devices but found Mac OS X infringed two of the patents related to graphic compression, will be vacated. Rulings by the US International Trade Commission are based upon valid patents. No matter what the finding by the ITC, the US Patent Office and the US Federal Courts are the only ones with the power to "invalidate" a patent issued in error. An invalid patent is no patent at all.

So, HTC is out $300 Million US, unless there was an out in the terms of the patent purchase agreement that insured against later invalidation by the PTO. But that also means, HTC has nothing to trade Apple to induce a patent cross-license agreement. That means a "read my lips, no HTC Android Phones that infringe on Apple Patents will be sold in the US"!

This is very bad news specifically for HTC and actually, the entire Android platform in general. The way patents work is that only one inventor can patent an exact technology. If any other Android handset maker has a patent that allows it to get around Apple's Patents they are all off the hook.

The normal result of a court finding of patent infringement is for the companies to license patents for an agreed royalty rate. It is all about money. With this spat, it is about market share and I don't think Apple is likely to allow infringing Android phones to be imported. Apple will continue to sue any infringement of iPhone and iPad technology and own the smartphone market and the touch screen tablet market.

Look for HTC's stock to continue to fall and a number of HTC Android handsets to be withdrawn from the market. The parallel litigation against Samsung and the other Android handset makers will likely have similar results. The only hope for any of the other Android handset makers is that they have enough patented technology that Apple absolutely has to have, that they can trade rights to.

Yesterday it came out that 35% of people surveyed intend to buy an iPhone 5, despite it having not even been announced. Apple, in my opinion, has a hammer lock on the smartphone and touch screen tablet market that the competition can't break. Watch for iPhone 5 and iPad 3 to sell out no matter how many they can make. That's Greg's Bite

 

Community Search:
MacTech Search:

Software Updates via MacUpdate

Latest Forum Discussions

See All

Take on the grandest beasts of all as th...
It has been hyped for a while but now it is finally here, the new Dancing in the Tempest season has arrived in Monster Hunter Now. Kicking off a banner summer for the game, it is time to strap on your boots and face the greatest threat yet, as the... | Read more »
The indie hit Vault of the Void will lan...
In a market where a lot of AAA games are starting to feel like reboots, remakes, or the same thing we’ve seen ten times with a different name slapped on it, indie developers are a boon. Especially ones who build a successful game singlehandedly,... | Read more »
Stumble Guys tries to catch up to the hy...
Do you remember when the Fallout TV series launched on Amazon and everyone nearly lost their minds? Well, it appears that Scopely missed that particular craze, and only now are we going to get a Fallout crossover, and by now, I mean in version 0.... | Read more »
Bid farewell to Penacony as Honkai: Star...
Penacony has been a story of twists, exciting new characters, and strong allies, and soon Honkai: Star Rail will be finishing it with a bang. Version 2.3, fittingly titled Farewell Penacony, will be launching June 19th and will feature updates to... | Read more »
HoYoverse roll out their plans for Anime...
For those who are looking to book a getaway in July, you might give some thought to Los Angeles between the 4th and 7th, which just so happens to coincide with the Anime Expo 2024. Amongst all the storied attendees is HoYoverse, who will be... | Read more »
The first rule of Brok the InvestiGator...
Mobile gamers were recently able to get their hands on BROK the InvestiGator, a point-and-click following the adventures of the titular reptile, a detective who can solve crimes through wit or brawn. If you were one that chose the latter then... | Read more »
Diablo Immortal celebrates second annive...
It has been two years since Diablo Immortal launched and despite some very valid criticism of its business model, it has done pretty well for itself. The Tempest class also gives it a lot of grace. To celebrate this anniversary, the March of the... | Read more »
Pokemon GO pulls on its jersey for a foo...
There have been a lot of jokes about this, some by me, but Pokemon Go has genuinely done a lot of good by getting people out and about.Pokemon GO Fest 2024: Madrid is fast approaching, and Niantic has set up a new area in a bit to get people to... | Read more »
Stumble Guys dials up the calamity 1000%...
Credit where it is due, Stumble Guys has had a few top-class crossovers in its’ life; Dungeons and Dragons, Rabbids and SpongeBob Squarepants to name but a few. It is such a shame, though, that all of these have now been well and truly trounced... | Read more »
You’re going to need a bigger boat as wa...
I am sure we all know that Finding Nemo quote of fish being friends and not food, however, Play Together is going in a completely opposite direction with their latest update. Introducing the Monstrous Fish, these behemoths are proving themselves... | Read more »

Price Scanner via MacPrices.net

New sale at Amazon: 16-inch M3 Pro and M3 Max...
Amazon is offering instant discounts on 16″ M3 Pro and 16″ M3 Max MacBook Pros ranging up to $350 off MSRP. Shipping is free. These are the lowest prices currently available for new 16″ Apple MacBook... Read more
Get a 13-inch M2 MacBook Air today at Apple f...
Apple has 13″ M2 MacBook Airs available for only $849 today in their Certified Refurbished store. These are the cheapest M2-powered MacBooks for sale at Apple. Apple’s one-year warranty is included,... Read more
Clearance Mac Studio with M1 Max CPU availabl...
Apple has clearance M1 Max Mac Studios available in their Certified Refurbished store for $270 off original MSRP. Each Mac Studio comes with Apple’s one-year warranty, and shipping is free: – Mac... Read more
Apple has 24-inch M3 iMacs on sale for $200-$...
Apple has a full line of 24-inch M3 iMacs available in their Certified Refurbished store starting at $1099 and ranging up to $260 off original MSRP. Each iMac is in like-new condition and comes with... Read more
24-inch M1 iMacs are available at Apple start...
Apple has clearance M1 iMacs available in their Certified Refurbished store starting at $1049 and ranging up to $300 off original MSRP. Each iMac is in like-new condition and comes with Apple’s... Read more
Back to School savings: Take $50-$100 off new...
Apple will take $50-$100 off new 11″ and 13″ M2 iPad Airs for all teachers, students, and staff of any educational institution with a .edu email address as part of their Apple Education discount,... Read more
Could A Smarter Siri Infused With AI (‘Apple...
FEATURE – The iPhone is already smart, but it’s about to become more intelligent. AI — short for artificial intelligence — is widely expected to be the main topic of discussion at this year’s WWDC (... Read more
Update: For WWDC, Amazon has lowered prices o...
Amazon has every configuration and color of Apple’s M3 MacBook Airs now on sale for $170-$210 off MSRP, starting at only $899 shipped, as Apple holds their annual WWDC conference this week. Their... Read more
Deal Alert! 2nd-generation Apple AirPods on s...
Amazon has 2nd generation Apple AirPods on sale right now for only $79.99 shipped. That’s $50 (38%) off Apple’s MSRP. Their price is the lowest currently available for a new set of AirPods from any... Read more
13-inch M3 MacBook Airs on sale for $150-$200...
Amazon has every configuration and color of Apple’s 13″ M3 MacBook Air on sale for $150-$200 off MSRP, now starting at only $899 shipped. Their prices are the lowest available for these Airs among... Read more

Jobs Board

Operations Associate - *Apple* Blossom Mall...
Operations Associate - Apple Blossom Mall Location:Winchester, VA, United States (https://jobs.jcp.com/jobs/location/191170/winchester-va-united-states) - Apple Read more
Cashier - *Apple* Blossom Mall - JCPenney (...
Cashier - Apple Blossom Mall Location:Winchester, VA, United States (https://jobs.jcp.com/jobs/location/191170/winchester-va-united-states) - Apple Blossom Mall Read more
Omnichannel Associate - *Apple* Blossom Mal...
Omnichannel Associate - Apple Blossom Mall Location:Winchester, VA, United States (https://jobs.jcp.com/jobs/location/191170/winchester-va-united-states) - Apple Read more
Sr Software Engineer, *Apple* iOS and tvOS...
…team drives innovation at scale for millions of consumers around the world across Apple , Android, Smart TVs, game consoles, and the web, with our platforms powering Read more
Senior Manager-Strategic Digital Payments Par...
…launching, managing, and expanding new digital payments products and partnerships, including Apple Pay, Google Pay, Samsung Pay, Meta, and other emerging players in Read more
All contents are Copyright 1984-2011 by Xplain Corporation. All rights reserved. Theme designed by Icreon.