Greg's Bite: high tech patent suits
TweetFollow Us on Twitter

Greg's Bite: high tech patent suits

By Greg Mills

The tech news has had a lot of stories regarding patent enforcement suits lately. Apple is plaintiff in a number of suits against almost every other electronic device company out there. The smartphone war is being fought in both the market place and in the court room.

You have certainly noticed the notation something like US 7,554,332 or Patent Pending on many of the products you buy. Those numbers are US patent serial numbers as some aspect or design element of the product has been found by the US Patent Office to be not obvious and both novel and useful. US Patents have evolved over the years, but, actually, the right to patent novel inventions is specifically provided for in the US Constitution.

The US government has the sole authority to issue US patents. The US Patent office wades through hundreds of thousands of patent applications each year. A lot of patent applications are denied, and a patent is never issued for the invention as the PTO (Patent and Trademark Office) has found that the invention actually was invented earlier by someone else. Another reason patent applications are bounced is because of obviousness.

Obviousness is in the eye of the beholder. Sometimes what seems obvious when you hold it in your hands was not so obvious when the inventor struggled to create the new product. Sometimes the invention is so breathtakingly elegant that it seems like anyone skilled in the trade could have created it. But if they didn't create it and someone who was working on the problem did create it, there may be a dispute over the obviousness of the invention.

I saw a chart showing who was suing whom in the smartphone business. It reminded me of a bowl of spaghetti and meat balls. The scramble to innovate and patent smartphone technology has been amazing. The billions of dollars at stake have pitched Apple, Google, Microsoft, Nokia, RIM, HTC, Samsung and a host of other companies into a mud wrestling pit where those with the most patents tend to win.

A trend has emerged where the actual authority to enforce US Patents, the US Federal Court System has become so bogged down, the players have turned to another venue to effectively enforce their US Patents. The US International Trade Commission has the power to stop the importation of any product that infringes upon any valid US Patent. The ITC moves much more quickly than the Federal Courts but has no power to award damages or to actually invalidate patents that were erroneously issued by the US Patent Office, in the first place.

It takes at least a couple of years and often much longer to work a patent through the PTO. It takes even longer to take a patent infringement suit to trial in a Federal Court. The time it takes for inventions to be protected and enforced is so long, the technology is often obsolete by the time a Federal Judge bangs the hammer down on his desk. Then the appeals start which takes years and hundreds of thousands of dollars to press. The patent system is indeed broken. The quality of patents issued is also disturbingly flawed, quite often.

Patents once issued are only a license to sue to protect what was patented in Federal Court. The US International Trade Commission has developed a much faster method of enforcing infringement if the resulting product is imported. Since the cost of making things in the Untied States is normally prohibitive compared to the likes of China, most everything is manufactured somewhere else around the world. Even US companies like Apple are subject to the International Trade Commission as nearly everything they sell is imported from the country where it was assembled.

Findings of infringement by the ITC can make or break a company long before a Federal Law suit can be heard. The way if seems to work is that companies file complaints against each other and the ITC staff sorts the complaints out using the same logic that the US Patent Office and the Federal Court use, but on a much faster track. With an order to stop importing a product that infringes on a valid patent, the actual stopping of the import of offending products at the dock may be followed later by a similar finding by the Federal Courts and an award of damages.

Often the best way to settle patent disputes is to agree on a royalty rate and damages for prior importation and then both companies go on. Sometimes the companies will cross license each other on patents they both need to freely import their products. Having a large patent portfolio is very helpful in the horse trading and royalty settlement game. You can play hard ball and not accept a royalty forcing infringing products to be banned. Apple is unlikey to license its technology unless they are forced to cross license patent rights. HTC is very worried right now.

Google, with its Android OS, has a remarkably small patent portfolio and that is why they were so disappointed when Apple and the rest of the gang won the recent Norvel Patent auction by out bid them. Apple intends to beat Android in the ITC and the courts and compete in the market place with innovation. The competition between giants companies with billions of dollars to throw around has jacked up the value of patents remarkably.

Companies that are patent rich and cash poor are now offering their patent portfolios to cash rich companies. Look for Apple to buy both patents and companies that own relevant technology rights as the smartphone legal saga goes on. The slate computer market is also going to foster serious spats that have already been filed but not heard yet. I would not be surprised to see Apple buy Kodak, for example.

When you hear sour grapes from HTC that Apple isn't playing fair by suing, instead of ignoring the ovious infringement of valid Apple patents and not just duking it out in the market place "man to man", you can feel their sense of impending doom. Even Google, when they lost the Norvel patent auction publicly stated that the patent process is broken. I agree, but you have to work with the system that is in place and Apple is doing that.

That is Greg's Bite for today

 

Community Search:
MacTech Search:

Software Updates via MacUpdate

Latest Forum Discussions

See All

Take on the grandest beasts of all as th...
It has been hyped for a while but now it is finally here, the new Dancing in the Tempest season has arrived in Monster Hunter Now. Kicking off a banner summer for the game, it is time to strap on your boots and face the greatest threat yet, as the... | Read more »
The indie hit Vault of the Void will lan...
In a market where a lot of AAA games are starting to feel like reboots, remakes, or the same thing we’ve seen ten times with a different name slapped on it, indie developers are a boon. Especially ones who build a successful game singlehandedly,... | Read more »
Stumble Guys tries to catch up to the hy...
Do you remember when the Fallout TV series launched on Amazon and everyone nearly lost their minds? Well, it appears that Scopely missed that particular craze, and only now are we going to get a Fallout crossover, and by now, I mean in version 0.... | Read more »
Bid farewell to Penacony as Honkai: Star...
Penacony has been a story of twists, exciting new characters, and strong allies, and soon Honkai: Star Rail will be finishing it with a bang. Version 2.3, fittingly titled Farewell Penacony, will be launching June 19th and will feature updates to... | Read more »
HoYoverse roll out their plans for Anime...
For those who are looking to book a getaway in July, you might give some thought to Los Angeles between the 4th and 7th, which just so happens to coincide with the Anime Expo 2024. Amongst all the storied attendees is HoYoverse, who will be... | Read more »
The first rule of Brok the InvestiGator...
Mobile gamers were recently able to get their hands on BROK the InvestiGator, a point-and-click following the adventures of the titular reptile, a detective who can solve crimes through wit or brawn. If you were one that chose the latter then... | Read more »
Diablo Immortal celebrates second annive...
It has been two years since Diablo Immortal launched and despite some very valid criticism of its business model, it has done pretty well for itself. The Tempest class also gives it a lot of grace. To celebrate this anniversary, the March of the... | Read more »
Pokemon GO pulls on its jersey for a foo...
There have been a lot of jokes about this, some by me, but Pokemon Go has genuinely done a lot of good by getting people out and about.Pokemon GO Fest 2024: Madrid is fast approaching, and Niantic has set up a new area in a bit to get people to... | Read more »
Stumble Guys dials up the calamity 1000%...
Credit where it is due, Stumble Guys has had a few top-class crossovers in its’ life; Dungeons and Dragons, Rabbids and SpongeBob Squarepants to name but a few. It is such a shame, though, that all of these have now been well and truly trounced... | Read more »
You’re going to need a bigger boat as wa...
I am sure we all know that Finding Nemo quote of fish being friends and not food, however, Play Together is going in a completely opposite direction with their latest update. Introducing the Monstrous Fish, these behemoths are proving themselves... | Read more »

Price Scanner via MacPrices.net

New sale at Amazon: 16-inch M3 Pro and M3 Max...
Amazon is offering instant discounts on 16″ M3 Pro and 16″ M3 Max MacBook Pros ranging up to $350 off MSRP. Shipping is free. These are the lowest prices currently available for new 16″ Apple MacBook... Read more
Get a 13-inch M2 MacBook Air today at Apple f...
Apple has 13″ M2 MacBook Airs available for only $849 today in their Certified Refurbished store. These are the cheapest M2-powered MacBooks for sale at Apple. Apple’s one-year warranty is included,... Read more
Clearance Mac Studio with M1 Max CPU availabl...
Apple has clearance M1 Max Mac Studios available in their Certified Refurbished store for $270 off original MSRP. Each Mac Studio comes with Apple’s one-year warranty, and shipping is free: – Mac... Read more
Apple has 24-inch M3 iMacs on sale for $200-$...
Apple has a full line of 24-inch M3 iMacs available in their Certified Refurbished store starting at $1099 and ranging up to $260 off original MSRP. Each iMac is in like-new condition and comes with... Read more
24-inch M1 iMacs are available at Apple start...
Apple has clearance M1 iMacs available in their Certified Refurbished store starting at $1049 and ranging up to $300 off original MSRP. Each iMac is in like-new condition and comes with Apple’s... Read more
Back to School savings: Take $50-$100 off new...
Apple will take $50-$100 off new 11″ and 13″ M2 iPad Airs for all teachers, students, and staff of any educational institution with a .edu email address as part of their Apple Education discount,... Read more
Could A Smarter Siri Infused With AI (‘Apple...
FEATURE – The iPhone is already smart, but it’s about to become more intelligent. AI — short for artificial intelligence — is widely expected to be the main topic of discussion at this year’s WWDC (... Read more
Update: For WWDC, Amazon has lowered prices o...
Amazon has every configuration and color of Apple’s M3 MacBook Airs now on sale for $170-$210 off MSRP, starting at only $899 shipped, as Apple holds their annual WWDC conference this week. Their... Read more
Deal Alert! 2nd-generation Apple AirPods on s...
Amazon has 2nd generation Apple AirPods on sale right now for only $79.99 shipped. That’s $50 (38%) off Apple’s MSRP. Their price is the lowest currently available for a new set of AirPods from any... Read more
13-inch M3 MacBook Airs on sale for $150-$200...
Amazon has every configuration and color of Apple’s 13″ M3 MacBook Air on sale for $150-$200 off MSRP, now starting at only $899 shipped. Their prices are the lowest available for these Airs among... Read more

Jobs Board

Operations Associate - *Apple* Blossom Mall...
Operations Associate - Apple Blossom Mall Location:Winchester, VA, United States (https://jobs.jcp.com/jobs/location/191170/winchester-va-united-states) - Apple Read more
Cashier - *Apple* Blossom Mall - JCPenney (...
Cashier - Apple Blossom Mall Location:Winchester, VA, United States (https://jobs.jcp.com/jobs/location/191170/winchester-va-united-states) - Apple Blossom Mall Read more
Omnichannel Associate - *Apple* Blossom Mal...
Omnichannel Associate - Apple Blossom Mall Location:Winchester, VA, United States (https://jobs.jcp.com/jobs/location/191170/winchester-va-united-states) - Apple Read more
Sr Software Engineer, *Apple* iOS and tvOS...
…team drives innovation at scale for millions of consumers around the world across Apple , Android, Smart TVs, game consoles, and the web, with our platforms powering Read more
Senior Manager-Strategic Digital Payments Par...
…launching, managing, and expanding new digital payments products and partnerships, including Apple Pay, Google Pay, Samsung Pay, Meta, and other emerging players in Read more
All contents are Copyright 1984-2011 by Xplain Corporation. All rights reserved. Theme designed by Icreon.