TweetFollow Us on Twitter

Apple's Transition from Open Firmware to Extensible Firmware Interface

Volume Number: 23 (2007)
Issue Number: 05
Column Tag: System Technologies

Apple's Transition from Open Firmware to Extensible Firmware Interface

By Criss Myers

Preface

In January 2006, Apple introduced Intel Architecture based Macs. They took this hardware move as an opportunity to also upgrade their choice of firmware. Their previous firmware, Open Firmware, was not in itself a bad choice, being far more advanced than the IBM PC BIOS that Windows computers use. There is, however, a better firmware choice that offers improvements on Open Firmware, called Extensible Firmware Interface, EFI, developed by Intel. When Apple looked for a successor to their PowerPC Processors, they found a complete hardware package from Intel. They got the latest CoreDuo and Xeon Processors, as well as advancements in boot firmware and disk partitioning. Since Apple offers an integrated package, this enables them to control all aspects of the computer system from processors to boot firmware to operating system. This also enabled them to make a smooth transition from the PowerPC, Open Firmware, APM and their 32bit OS, to Intel processors, EFI, GPT and 64bit Tiger OS X. Anyone using these 2 systems will not notice any difference apart from their performance. In this article we will take a brief look at Open Firmware and then explain what EFI is, its history, and what this means for Apple's future as well as that of the PC market in general.

Open Firmware

Apple's PowerPC Macs, post-NuBus, used a boot firmware called Open Firmware. Open Firmware, also called OpenBoot, was developed by Sun Microsystems and is used in Sun's Sparc work stations and servers, IBM POWER systems and PegasosPPC systems and is available under a BSD license. It was described by IEEE as IEEE 1275-1994 but since 1998, it has been withdrawn. In 2006 several commercial versions were released to the open source community under the OpenBIOS project, these include, SUN OpenBOOT, Firmworks OpenFirmware and Codegen SmartFirmware. Open Firmware is a hardware independent firmware and fulfils the same tasks as BIOS does in a PC. The advantage of Open Firmware to Apple is that any I/O cards that work, in say SUN machines, could also be used in Mac machines without requiring any specific Mac drivers. Open Firmware also offered BOOTP capabilities for Netbooting machines as well as setting boot devices. On a Macintosh, most user settings can be changed via GUI tools and the Open Firmware can be locked to prevent booting from non-authorized sources.

Extensible Firmware Interface (EFI)

History

EFI was developed by Andrew Fish working for Intel back in the 1990's and was initially called "Intel Boot Initiative (IBI)". It grew up around the need to replace the aging PC BIOS developed by IBM in the 1970's. IBI was intended for their Itanium Architecture (IA) based computers because the existing PC BIOS was far too limiting for future 64 bit operating systems, some of these problems being 16 bit processor mode and PC AT hardware dependencies to name a few. Since then, IBI was developed by Intel into EFI and subsequently released by them to the open source community in 2005. It is now called UEFI (Unified Extensible Firmware Interface) and is currently at version 2.1.

Due to the failed performance of these IA machines, EFI never took off as a common replacement for the PC BIOS. In 2006, Apple moved to EFI and was then the only vendor to take advantage of this firmware interface. Linux has supported EFI since 2000 using "elilo" as a boot loader and both Windows and HP-UX support EFI, but all of these only support IA-32 and IA-64 platforms. Windows Vista is expected to support EFI but only in a later service pack and Microsoft's stance is that until EFI becomes mainstream they will not support it.

What is EFI?

EFI was designed to abstract the firmware and hardware layers from the operating system layer. This is so that operating system vendors and developers no longer need to battle with cumbersome 16bit BIOS and constant hardware configurations.


Fig 1. Legacy PC BIOS vs. EFI

Figure 1 compares EFI and BIOS showing EFI as a standard interface between the OS and the hardware. EFI is a set of specifications to define interactions and programmatic interfaces between the hardware and the operating systems, it is then up to the specific hardware vendors to make an EFI compliant system. Since EFI is just a set of specifications, it is not an actual firmware; therefore, it is up to each vendor to create their own firmware to initialize their hardware. Intel's firmware, and hence Apple's choice, is called "Intel Platform Innovation Framework for EFI", also called "Framework". It is a legacy free firmware that complies with EFI. It is not available to end-users as a complete firmware package but parts of the code are released under the TianoCore project, (www.tianocore.org). Apple created their own version of "Framework"; we will see later how they implemented EFI and framework.

EFI is very similar to Open Firmware in that it is a boot firmware independent of hardware and operating system. What this means is that it allows the operating system to boot and run in a "sandbox" mode. A "sandbox" mode is a safe protected mode where the operating system does not make direct calls to the hardware. EFI controls the hardware; it takes the calls from the operating system, and then passes them on to the hardware, creating an interface between the OS and the physical firmware, in much the same way that a virtual machine works. This then offers a stable environment from which to run the OS. The advantage of this is that only the firmware controls the hardware (see Fig 2).


Figure 2 - EFI as an interface between the OS and the Firmware

For developers this means they will no longer need to make BIOS/OS dependant drivers, they can create EFI based drivers which will then work in any compatible EFI machine irrelevant of the OS or BIOS loaded. Obviously, for Apple this means a wider range of I/O cards can be supported in the future once more hardware vendors support EFI. EFI is free of any of the memory restrictions that BIOS has and can use all available memory. This speeds up boot time as well, a Mac Pro for instance can boot up and load the OS in just 15 seconds.

The EFI specification is broken down into "boot services" and "runtime services". Boot Services are any services that run during boot only, such as, the loading of drivers and the accessing of graphics during boot. The services use "EFI Drivers" "EFI Applications" and "EFI Boot Code". Runtime Services run while the computer is running accessing such things as date/time etc. EFI Drivers are written in C and conform to the EFI Drivers Model. They can be loaded from any non-volatile memory, either in option ROM, or on the device directly.

Apple's implementation of EFI and Framework

The EFI Boot Process

Firstly, the computer powers up, then Framework, then, via EFI boot services, initializes the hardware such as the Bluetooth, USB, VGA, network IP stack, remote control, etc. These boot services will load all the hardware drivers necessary to detect any OS that resides on either an internal or external hard disk, or a network volume. Apple's Framework does not boot into text mode but directly into graphics mode, just like it did with Open Firmware. There is no direct access to the text mode or EFI shell. Apple has developed their Framework to work in much the same way as Open Firmware did, using the same key strokes: C boots to CD/DVD, N boots into the Netboot disk, V boots verbose and S boots into Safe Mode, etc. This makes a seamless transition from Open Firmware to EFI for the user.

Following this, various EFI Applications can be loaded; one such application is the Boot Manager. The Boot Manager is used to select and load the operating system, removing the need for a dedicated boot-loader mechanism. On an Apple this looks very similar to the Open Firmware boot-loader but with updated graphics. Apple has created their own EFI compliant Boot Manager with their own graphics. Apple's Boot Manager can detect any Mac operating system that is available to the system. According to Apple, their EFI Application can, however, only read boot-code from a GPT formatted drive or an Intel based NetBoot image; only one Netboot image is displayed and is either set via the "Startup Disk" section on the client or is the default image set on the server. Initially the Boot Manager could only detect Mac OS, but Apple used the "compatibility support module" to support legacy PC BIOS such as XP. This will only display a single legacy OS per drive.


Figure 3 - EFI with the CSM Module

Apple's Boot Manager Application will either boot from the default volume or you can enter the graphical selection screen via the option keystroke, just as with Open Firmware. The EFI boot code is then read from the hard disk and the operating system is loaded. Control is then transferred to the OS. Some higher operating system drivers can now be loaded for various devices. The operating system will then pass calls to the firmware, which will pass them to the hardware.


Figure 4 - EFI Boot Process

rEFIt tools

When Apple released BootCamp with their Firmware update, which added the compatibility support module to their firmware, it became possible to load the Linux OS onto a Mac. However, this module only recognizes a single legacy OS per drive and labels them as Windows only. This is not useful in a triple boot system. An open source project was then started called rEFIt tools which offers a boot menu to detect multiple OS per drive and label them as the appropriate OS's. It also offers a maintenance toolkit with direct access to the EFI pre-boot environment and gives access to the EFI Shell Application. The current version is 0.8 and can be loaded via CD, USB or directly off the internal drive. When you boot the Mac with the option key held down, you can then select the rEFIt tools from their installed location.

Conclusion -- Future Benefits of EFI for Apple

EFI is a complete pre-boot environment, that makes life much easier for developers, and since EFI is written in C, it is much easier to program for. With more vendors supporting this specification it means, for Apple users, that more and more devices with be compatible with Macs. This can only be a good thing. Developers find it a much easier environment to develop in due to its pre-boot environment. They can test and develop without the need for a VDU because they can output the tests directly to text. The pre-boot environment can also be used for backup, recovery, and diagnostics, updating firmware by accessing the Internet without the need for an OS. Both American Megatrends Inc (AMI) and Insyde Technology, both members of UEFI, have made Pre-Boot Applications sets.


Figure 5 - AMI Pre-Boot Interface

There are development tools available that allow users to create their own pre-boot applications.


Figure 6 - Pre-Boot Applications

This offers Apple the chance to create their own Pre-Boot Applications which can be stored on the System EFI partition, which is currently empty on Apples GPT drives, but is created by default with a set size of 200mb. Apple could develop pre-boot versions of Time Machine for Leopard so that an OS X system could be recovered via an existing backup, or use a pre-boot Disk Utility to repair a drive. Third party companies such as Norton or Tech Tool could install pre-boot versions of their Applications to this hidden partition also. Apple could also make a pre-boot version of Front Row so that users can access their DVD's, MP3s, AppleTV without needing to boot the OS. This also offers secure network booting, remote provisioning and setup as well as virus scanning etc. For the general user it will offer them a stable environment to run the Mac OS X without as many kernel panics.

Bibliography and References

UEFI. UEFI Extensible Firmware Interface Specifications Version 2.1, Copyright 2006.

Windows Hardware Developer Central, EFI and Windows, April 2006.

Wikipedia, Extensible Firmware Interface, 2007.

Wikipedia, Open Firmware, 2007.

Wikipedia, BIOS, 2007.

OSX86Project, EFI, February 2007.

Intel Software Network, Extensible Firmware Interface, 2006.

Intel Software Network, Enhanced Pre-Boot Environments with EFI Applications, 2007

Michael Kinney - Intel Developer Update Magazine, Solving Boot Issues with EFI, September 2000

Amit Singh - Kernelthread.com, More Power to Firmware, Copyright 2006.

American Megatrends Inc, AMI Pre-Boot Applications, December 2005.


Criss Myers is a Senior Mac IT Technician for the Faculty of Science and Technology, at the University of Central Lancashire, Preston, United Kingdom. He has been a Systems Server Administrator from the very first version of OS X Server. He Works with Macs as well as Linux, Unix and Windows.

 

Community Search:
MacTech Search:

Software Updates via MacUpdate

WhatsApp 2.2136.10 - Desktop client for...
WhatsApp is the desktop client for WhatsApp Messenger, a cross-platform mobile messaging app which allows you to exchange messages without having to pay for SMS. WhatsApp Messenger is available for... Read more
Thunderbird 91.1.1 - Email client from M...
As of July 2012, Thunderbird has transitioned to a new governance model, with new features being developed by the broader free software and open source community, and security fixes and improvements... Read more
Direct Mail 5.9.1 - Create and send grea...
Direct Mail is an easy-to-use, fully-featured email marketing app purpose-built for macOS. Create, send, and track great looking email campaigns that get results. Start your newsletter by selecting... Read more
LibreOffice 7.2.1.2 - Free, open-source...
LibreOffice is an office suite (word processor, spreadsheet, presentations, drawing tool) compatible with other major office suites. The Document Foundation is coordinating development and... Read more
Steam 2.0 - Multiplayer and communicatio...
Steam is a digital distribution, digital rights management, multiplayer and communications platform developed by Valve Corporation. It is used to distribute a large number of games and related media... Read more
Adobe Acrobat DC 21.007.20091 - Powerful...
Acrobat DC is available only as a part of Adobe Creative Cloud, and can only be installed and/or updated through Adobe's Creative Cloud app. Adobe Acrobat DC with Adobe Document Cloud services is... Read more
Carbon Copy Cloner 6.0.3 - Easy-to-use b...
Carbon Copy Cloner backups are better than ordinary backups. Suppose the unthinkable happens while you're under deadline to finish a project: your Mac is unresponsive and all you hear is an ominous,... Read more
Adobe Animate 21.0.9 - Animation authori...
Adobe Animate is available as part of Adobe Creative Cloud for as little as $20.99/month (or $9.99/month if you're a previous Flash Professional customer). Adobe Animate (was Flash CC) lets you share... Read more
Vivaldi 4.2.2406.44 - An advanced browse...
Vivaldi is a browser for our friends. We live in our browsers. Choose one that has the features you need, a style that fits and values you can stand by. From the look and feel, to how you interact... Read more
Adobe Acrobat Reader 2021.007.20091 - Vi...
Adobe Acrobat Reader allows users to view PDF documents. You may not know what a PDF file is, but you've probably come across one at some point. PDF files are used by companies and even the IRS to... Read more

Latest Forum Discussions

See All

PUBG New State crosses 40 million pre-re...
PUBG New State has received over 40 million pre-registrations on both Android and iOS, Krafton has recently announced. The futuristic, sci-fi PUBG Mobiletitle is all set to launch later this year, in October. [Read more] | Read more »
A Mere Husk of a Human Being – The Touch...
In this week’s episode of The TouchArcade Show I continue to be more or less out of my mind due to the exhaustion of having a newborn baby. Yes, I’ve been through all this before with our previous child, but somehow this is kicking my ass even worse... | Read more »
TouchArcade Game of the Week: ‘Night in...
I have said this probably dozens of times over the years, but there are tons and tons of cool video games on non-mobile platforms that people gush about all the time, and I always tell myself “I’ll definitely get around to playing that myself on [... | Read more »
SwitchArcade Round-Up: ‘Ni no Kuni II’,...
Hello gentle readers, and welcome to the SwitchArcade Round-Up for September 17th, 2021. In today’s article, we finish our look at the new games of the week with the Friday releases. Some fairly big games in the list today, like Ni no Kuni II:... | Read more »
‘LEGO Star Wars Battles’ from TT Games a...
Last month, LEGO Star Wars Battles () was revealed for Apple Arcade. | Read more »
COD Mobile: The 5 best SMGs in the game
COD Mobile is often lauded for its vast array of weapons and elaborate customization. With every update, the guns get some kind of nerfs or buffs. Regardless of that, SMGs remain popular with players for close to mid-range combat. [Read more] | Read more »
SEGA Will Reveal a New Mobile RPG at Tok...
A few days ago, there was a bit of buzz around the listing of a new RPG under SEGA / Atlus for Tokyo Game Show 2021. Tokyo Game Show 2021 begins later this month and both SEGA and Atlus will have games and updates to showcase. SEGA will be revealing... | Read more »
‘Castlevania: Grimoire of Souls’ and ‘Te...
This week’s Apple Arcade roundup has updates to four amazing games on the service and the addition of two new games. The first new game is Castlevania: Grimoire of Souls () from Konami. | Read more »
‘Indies’ Lies’ is a New Roguelike Deck B...
For several years, as the popularity of MegaCrit’s roguelike deck-building game Slay the Spire grew amongst PC gamers, lots and lots of mobile gamers hoped that the game would one day arrive on their mobile devices, where it seemed like a natural... | Read more »
‘Steam Highwayman: Smog & Ambuscade’...
Cubus Games have released a number of interesting gamebooks on mobile for a number of years now, including titles such as Heavy Metal Thunder and The Frankenstein Wars. Now at the end of this month they’ll be adding another to their catalogue with a... | Read more »

Price Scanner via MacPrices.net

This is the final week for Apple’s 2021 Back...
Apple’s Back to School promotion for 2021 continues through September 27, 2021, making this the final full week to take advantage of these offers. As part of this promotion, Apple will include one... Read more
Verizon offers $100 discount on Apple’s new 8...
Verizon has Apple’s new 8.3-inch iPad mini and 9th-generation iPad on sale for $100 off MSRP with an Unlimited service plan. Discount is for 64GB and 256GB cellular-enabled models. The $100 sale... Read more
Apple’s new 9th generation iPad and 8.3-inch...
Amazon is offering preorder discounts on Apple’s new 9th generation iPad and 8.3″ iPad mini (64GB WiFi models) ranging up to $40 off MSRP. Delivery is expected starting September 24th: iPad: – 10″... Read more
Xfinity Mobile offers new Apple iPhone 13 mod...
Xfinity Mobile has Apple’s new iPhone 13 family of smartphones on sale and available for preorder for $300 off MSRP for customers opening a new line of service. No trade-in is required. Cost of the... Read more
Verizon offers free Apple iPhone 13 and iPhon...
Verizon is offering an $800 discount on Apple’s new iPhone 13 and $700 discount on the iPhone 13 mini for new and existing customers with a qualified trade-in. Price of the iPhone 13 will be spread... Read more
Apple Product Announcements, As Of Late, Have...
COMMENTARY: 09.17.21 – If you were left feeling a little, “meh” following Apple’s latest product launch, you’re not alone. On Tuesday — in a pre-recorded virtual event dubbed, “California Streaming... Read more
Verizon offers 25% discount on Apple MagSafe...
Verizon has Apple MagSafe Chargers on sale for 25% off MSRP from 9/16/21 to 9/30/21. Verizon service is not required to take advantage of these savings. With the discount, Verizon’s sale prices are... Read more
Verizon offers $1000 discount on new Apple iP...
Verizon is offering a $1000 discount on Apple’s new iPhone 13 Pro and iPhone 13 Pro Max for new and existing customers with a qualified trade-in. Price of the iPhone 13 Pro will be spread over 24 or... Read more
New at AT&T: Apple iPhone 13 and 13 mini...
We’ve already told you about AT&T’s $1000 discounts on the Apple iPhone 13 Pro and iPhone 13 Pro Max. AT&T now has Apple’s new iPhone 13 and iPhone 13 mini discounted to $700 off MSRP for new... Read more
‘Mac Potpourri’ Story On Apple And Folding Sm...
FEATURE: 09.16.21 – A certain writer has been seemingly thrust into the limelight thanks to an article published last month on MacPrices. The article — a commentary on how Apple must “‘flip’ the... Read more

Jobs Board

Geek Squad *Apple* Consultation Professiona...
**829606BR** **Job Title:** Geek Squad Apple Consultation Professional **Job Category:** Store Associates **Store Number or Department:** 001422-Tualatin-Store **Job Read more
Geek Squad Advanced Repair *Apple* Professi...
**831864BR** **Job Title:** Geek Squad Advanced Repair Apple Professional **Job Category:** Store Associates **Store Number or Department:** 000011-Northtown-Store Read more
Geek Squad *Apple* Consultation Professiona...
**831828BR** **Job Title:** Geek Squad Apple Consultation Professional **Job Category:** Store Associates **Store Number or Department:** 000028-Green Bay-Store Read more
Sr Infrastructure Engineer - *Apple* MacInt...
**Sr Infrastructure Engineer - Apple MacIntosh** **Description** At Bank of the West, our people are having a positive impact on the world. We're investing where we Read more
Senior Software Developer - *Apple* (iOS/tv...
**SUMMARY** Hulu's Apple team is seeking an experienced Senior Software Engineer with a passion for mobile applications to join our team in Seattle. Our highly Read more
All contents are Copyright 1984-2011 by Xplain Corporation. All rights reserved. Theme designed by Icreon.