TweetFollow Us on Twitter

Enabling CGI Scripts, The Second

Volume Number: 19 (2003)
Issue Number: 10
Column Tag: Programming

Untangling the Web

Enabling CGI Scripts, The Second

by Kevin Hemenway

You've enabled CGI, but how do you know it's good?

In the last issue, we learned about CGI scripts: what they are, what they can do, how they're already enabled within Apache, and how to tweak that configuration to be more URL friendly. What we didn't do is teach you anything for the future: at most, we brought a wide-eyed wonder-boy to a patch of poison ivy, and backed away slowly. Will he rub it on his skinned knee? Pin it to little Susie's dress as a token of his affection? Roll around in it like catnip? Where is the inbred fear necessary for every child's survival?

Insert transitional one-liner here!

Dissection--Similarities

Before we can understand, be aware, and watch for the security ramifications of running CGI scripts from unknown and untrusted third parties, we need to see how they're coded, how poorly written ones can ruin our mornings, and how to look for some semblance of quality. The quickest way to get a general feel is with the two sample scripts already installed with Apache: /Library/WebServer/CGI-Executables/printenv and /Library/WebServer/CGI-Executables/printenv/test-cgi. If you looked at their source code last month, you may have noticed they're written in two different languages.

The smaller of the two scripts, test-cgi, starts with #!/bin/sh, whereas printenv instead uses #!/usr/bin/perl -T. These lines, specifically the #! prefix, are often called the "shebang", and tell us which interpreter will execute the programming instructions that follow. The interpreter located at /bin/sh, rarely seen in production CGI, indicates that the rest of the code is written in the shell scripting language. Any CGI script you deploy will need to have some sort of shebang--whether it's /bin/sh, /usr/bin/perl, /usr/bin/python or something else entirely, it's absolutely required. Not only is it necessary, it also has to be accurate: if your only Perl is /sw/bin/perl, then the shebang should point there instead. Shebangs can also contain command line arguments: in printenv, -T is passed directly to the /usr/bin/perl interpreter (where it means something we'll cover a bit later).

Another similar difference between our two scripts is the printing of something called a Content-type (Listing 1), which tell the requesting user-agent (your visitor's browser) what sort of data it's about to receive (an image to render, text to display, XML to parse, etc.). The Content-type will never actually be shown in your final output--it's hidden pixie dust for the browser's benefit only (if you're curious, Mozilla allows you to view the Content-type by getting the "Page Info" of the current URL). Without this crucial bit of contextual magic (and the two required newlines), Apache will fail your CGI scripts with an "Internal Server Error". This error is never a satisfying explanation--you'll need to check Apache's /var/log/httpd/error_log for the exact reasoning.

Listing 1: Printing the Content-type in Shell and Perl

From the sample CGI scripts printenv and test-cgi

# content type display from test-cgi
# note that echo spits out a newline,
# 2 echo's for the 2 required newlines.
echo Content-type: text/plain
echo
# and the similar entry from printenv
print "Content-type: text/html\n\n";

The values of our Content-types (text/plain and text/html) didn't just appear out of thin air--they're MIME types, and most any file you've ever worked with has one. You can find a large listing of MIME types, based on their common file extensions, by perusing the /etc/httpd/mime.types file. For example, the matching MIME types for JPEG, XHTML, Quicktime, and Microsoft Word files are:

image/jpeg                      jpeg jpg jpe
application/xhtml+xml           xhtml xht
video/quicktime                 qt mov
application/msword              doc

If you can't find the matching MIME type for the data you're interested in serving (either because it's not in the mime.types file or Google has spurned your search request), you can use the "some sort of data" MIME type of application/octet-stream. This has already been explicitly assigned to a number of files, including Apple disk images:

application/octet-stream   dms lha lzh exe class so dll dmg

Dissection--Why The Perl Script Is Arguably Stronger

All CGI scripts, regardless of what they're programmed in, can be run from the command line--whether they actually do anything useful is a case-by-case basis. This is a surprisingly useful bit of information: since troubleshooting and debugging happens best when unfrilled by complication, removing Apache from the process can prove helpful. Running your CGI scripts on the command line can preemptively weed out problems like missing Content-type's, file permission errors, invalid syntax problems, missing language extensions, and so forth.

Both the test-cgi and printenv scripts run "successfully" at the command line, although only the first gives any useful output (Figure 1). Compare this to the regular browser-based output we demonstrated in the last MacTech (or simply re-access http://127.0.0.1/cgi-bin/test-cgi). The first line is that dastardly Content-type and, as mentioned before, is normally processed by the browser and removed from the final display. Since we're running the script without the benefit of a web server or browser, the Content-type is viewable without extra effort. This becomes a handy barometer: if you run your CGI script from the command line and there's no Content-type, it'll never run correctly under Apache.


Figure 1: The slightly undefined test-cgi, when run in the Terminal

But wait... there's no Content-type if we try to run printenv (in fact, there's nothing at all), so why does it work when we access it by URL (http://127.0.0.1/cgi-bin/printenv)? In actuality, this is one of the "strengths" of the Perl version. If you check the source code, the next line after our required shebang (ignoring comments) is:

exit unless ($ENV{'REQUEST_METHOD'} eq "GET");

This terminates the script unless it was invoked via a GET request. Generically speaking, unless it is a POST, every request a web browser makes is a GET with or without key/value pairs. Since the shell isn't a web browser, no GET is issued and the script terminates. If we wanted to get fancy, we could fake the required method by running setenv REQUEST_METHOD GET && ./printenv (if you're using the tsch shell; REQUEST_METHOD=GET ./printenv if you prefer bash). As a result, we get a Terminal full of HTML listing the environment variables. We can redirect this mass of HTML to a file by adding > output.html to our previous command line; Figure 2 shows the generated file.


Figure 2: Shell output of our tricked printenv script

Figure 2 also gives us another reason why the Perl script is stronger: it doesn't pretend to know what the environment is going to look like. test-cgi, hard-coded to display the values of known variables (SERVER_SOFTWARE, SERVER_NAME, GATEWAY_INTERFACE, etc.), shows nothing but undefined values when run from the Terminal (Figure 1), where those specific entries don't normally exist.

Three Ways Perl CGI Scripts Can Be Improved

The bulk of the code within the printenv script caters to creating a pretty HTML page, something not important to the true purpose of generating a list of the current environment. To make our upcoming improvements more clearly, we'll base our changes on the Perl script shown in Listing 2, which does the exact same thing as printenv, only without the HTML. For all intents and purposes, this is a working CGI script: it's got the shebang pointing to the correct Perl interpreter, and it prints a plain-text Content-type before any other data.

Note that even though we're talking specifically about CGI scripts, the following improvements can, and should, be made in most any Perl script, especially those to be used in production environments. Security should never be a feature.

Listing 2: Printing the environment more simply

Our base.pl script could use some improvements.

#!/usr/bin/perl
print "Content-type: text/plain\n\n";
foreach $var (keys %ENV) {
   print "$var = $ENV{$var}\n";
}

Save this file as base.pl and run it from the command line; my output is in Figure 3. None of our upcoming improvements will change this display and, as you can see by comparing it to Figure 2, it's identical save for the loss of HTML (and the differences between Safari and the Terminal's interpretation of TERMCAP).


Figure 3: Our rewritten script's (base.pl) output

Our improvements to the script are quite minimal additions, but they ensure that user data has been properly checked for dangerous input, warnings have been enabled for common mistakes or typos that don't necessarily stop a script from running, and a stricter development environment has been used to encourage stronger coding and careful variable declaration. The revised script is shown in Listing 3.

Listing 3: Printing the environment more strongly

Our revised script is three times stronger than before.

#!/usr/bin/perl -wT
use strict;
print "Content-type: text/plain\n\n";
foreach my $var (keys %ENV) {
   print "$var = $ENV{$var}\n";
}
  • Use warnings: The first change, adding -w to the shebang, turns on Perl's warnings pragma, which spits a list of optional, non-fatal warnings to STDERR (which becomes Apache's error_log when run as a CGI). Technically, you don't have to address any of the messages since the script will continue on regardless, but they'll alert you to typos, uninitialized values, deprecated functions, and a slew of other mishaps that can eventually escalate into full-blown bugs. Typically, the messages are terse enough to be useful for seasoned Perl programmers, but you can increase their verbosity by adding use diagnostics; within the body of your code.

  • Use strict: Our third and fourth changes complement our warnings. Perl's strict pragma should be used in any script that is more than "casual", and ensures that every variable is pre-declared and localized, and that other "unsafe constructs" are detected and addressed. Unlike warnings, any error that triggers strict will stop your script from continuing further. You'll notice that we've localized our $var variable with the my() function. The first time you use strict, it'll feel like an unwieldy and overly doting mother, but scripts that compile cleanly benefit from an attention to detail that strengthens their quality immensely.

  • Use taint: Even though it is "strongly recommended", very few Perl or CGI scripts use taint mode, which is what the -T on the shebang enables. Under this mode, any outside data received by your code is considered highly dangerous, and will cause script errors until it has been checked for safety. These safety checks can be as simple as ensuring that a command line argument only contains alphanumerics, or that the process you're spawning isn't being handed potentially damaging shell metacharacters. While taint mode will force you to focus more strongly about the evils of the outside world and exactly what data you expect, programmers who misunderstand how to "untaint" data may inadvertently do so incorrectly, creating a false sense of security.

These programming additions aren't the ultimately panacea, but merely a placebo. Yes, your code will be stronger with them, but that doesn't mean crucial bugs won't creep in and ruin your day. Serious coders and sysadmins should take a look at the following sampling of Perl and CGI security links:

  • The Perl Security manpage, accessible by typing man perlsec in your Terminal, can also be read online at http://www.perldoc.com/perl5.6.1/pod/perlsec.html

  • "Avoiding security holes when developing an application", a six part series from LinuxFocus.org: http://www.linuxfocus.org/English/November2001/article203.shtml

  • SecureProgramming (http://www.secureprogramming.com/) offers a huge collection of links to over 50 articles, books, recipes to learn from and adapt, and more.

  • RFP's "Perl CGI problems", which appeared in an old issue of the seminal Phrack magazine, still remains relevant: http://www.wiretrip.net/rfp/txt/phrack55.txt

  • CERT's "How To Remove Meta-characters From User-Supplied Data In CGI Scripts", in both Perl and C: http://www.cert.org/tech_tips/cgi_metacharacters.html. Handy for when you're looking to untaint some data.

  • The "Securing Programming for Linux and Unix HOWTO", available from http://en.tldp.org/HOWTO/Secure-Programs-HOWTO/. Similar articles like "The Hack FAQ" (http://www.nmrc.org/pub/faq/hackfaq/index.html), and the "WWW Security FAQ" (http://www.w3.org/Security/Faq/www-security-faq.html) will also prove insightful.

    Choosing a CGI Script for Deployment

    The above programming suggestions are fine if you're solely looking at the code quality of a potential CGI script, but there are few more areas to investigate before you can consider a program worthy of being installed on your server:

    • Check the Bugtraq archives (http://securityfocus.com/archive/1). Anyone interested in security should be reading Bugtraq, where a large community of hackers, white hats, sysadmins, and professionals regularly post bugs, exploits, and warnings for insecure products. Occasionally, you'll also see new whitepapers concerning various aspects of security and programming. Before installing new scripts, comb the archives to see if any advisories have been posted. If so, ensure they've been fixed before using the code.

    • Googling for problems can prove illuminating, as you'll often find common tech support problems, heaps of praise or scorn for the code or author, and occasionally, other web hosts who offer the script for their own customer base.

    • Check the dates: When was the script last updated? Is it so long ago that no one will give a darn if you have a problem? Just because a script doesn't have any reported problems in Bugtraq doesn't mean that it isn't susceptible to relatively new exploits like cross-site scripting attacks (http://www.cgisecurity.com/articles/xss-faq.shtml). Code that has been updated recently has a better chance of good turnaround time for crucial fixes, updates, and support.

    • Got logfiles? Most CGI scripts don't have any logging capability, primarily because they only do one small thing (like email forms, add one to a number, display a calendar, etc.) Some complicated scripts, however, can benefit from logging, especially those with built-in user authentication ("who is using my site?") or flaw tracking ("a bug occurred at [time], and things turned awry [like this]"). Scripts can use their own logfiles or Perl's Sys::Syslog module to log directly to /var/log/system.log.

      Homework Malignments

      In our next column, we'll move on to configuring PHP, as well as explain the up- and downsides between forking processes (like CGI) and embedded modules (like mod_php). We'll explore the default configuration of PHP, the non-existent configuration file (php.ini) and, if we have time, how to install MySQL and do a few integration tests. For now, students may contact the teacher at morbus@disobey.com.

    • Besides -w, you can also enable Perl's warning pragma with use warnings; (similar to use strict;). Subtle differences exist between the two--research them and find out which satisfies your programming needs better.

    • Any Perl script with logging may eventually run up against a perceived "buffering" problem, the sordid details of which are explained in Mark Jason Dominus' "Suffering from Buffering?" (http://perl.plover.com/FAQs/Buffering.html).

    • If you're looking to brush up on your Perl knowledge, you can't go wrong with O'Reilly's Learning Perl, The Perl Cookbook (which just received an impressive Second Edition update), and the recent Learning Perl Objects, References, & Modules. You can read sample chapters from all the books at http://www.oreilly.com/.


      Kevin Hemenway, coauthor of Mac OS X Hacks and Spidering Hacks, is better known as Morbus Iff, the creator of disobey.com, which bills itself as "content for the discontented." Publisher and developer of more home cooking than you could ever imagine (like the popular open-sourced aggregator AmphetaDesk, the best-kept gaming secret Gamegrene.com, the ever ignorable Nonsense Network), he's twirling his hair and trying not to cheerlead. Contact him at morbus@disobey.com.

  •  

    Community Search:
    MacTech Search:

    Software Updates via MacUpdate

    FileZilla 3.51.0 - Fast and reliable FTP...
    FileZilla (ported from Windows) is a fast and reliable FTP client and server with lots of useful features and an intuitive interface. Version 3.51.0: Bugfixes and minor changes: Fixed import of... Read more
    KeyCue 9.8 - Displays all menu shortcut...
    KeyCue has always been a handy tool for learning and remembering keyboard shortcuts. With a simple keystroke or click, KeyCue displays a table with all available keyboard shortcuts, system-wide... Read more
    AppCleaner 3.5.1 - Uninstall your apps e...
    AppCleaner allows you to uninstall your apps easily. It searches the files created by the applications and you can delete them quickly. Version 3.5.1: Fixed a code-signing issue causing AppCleaner... Read more
    A Better Finder Attributes 7.03 - Change...
    A Better Finder Attributes allows you to change JPEG & RAW shooting dates, JPEG EXIF meta-data tags, file creation & modification dates, file flags and deal with invisible files. Correct EXIF... Read more
    Postbox 7.0.33 - Powerful and flexible e...
    Postbox is a desktop feature-stuffed email client, news application, and feed reader that helps you manage your work life and increase productivity. Now you can organize all your email accounts in... Read more
    Adobe InCopy 16.0 - Create streamlined e...
    InCopy is available as part of Adobe Creative Cloud for $52.99/month (or $4.99/month for InCopy app only). Adobe InCopy, ideal for large team projects involving both written copy and design work,... Read more
    Steam 2.0 - Multiplayer and communicatio...
    Steam is a digital distribution, digital rights management, multiplayer and communications platform developed by Valve Corporation. It is used to distribute a large number of games and related media... Read more
    Adobe Lightroom Classic 10.0 - Import, d...
    You can download Lightroom for Mac as a part of Creative Cloud for only $9.99/month with Photoshop, included as part of the photography package. The latest version of Lightroom gives you all of the... Read more
    Adobe InDesign 16.0 - Professional print...
    InDesign is available as part of Adobe Creative Cloud for as little as $20.99/month (or $9.99/month if you're a previous InDesign customer). Adobe InDesign is part of Creative Cloud. That means you... Read more
    Adobe After Effects 17.5 - Create profes...
    After Effects is available as part of Adobe Creative Cloud for $52.99/month (or $20.99/month for a single app license). The new, more connected After Effects can make the impossible possible. Get... Read more

    Latest Forum Discussions

    See All

    Genshin Impact Currency Guide - What...
    Genshin Impact is great fun, but make no mistake: this is a gacha game. It is designed specifically to suck away time and money from you, and one of the ways the game does this is by offering a drip-feed of currencies you will feel compelled to... | Read more »
    XCOM 2 Collection on iOS now available f...
    The XCOM 2 Collection, which was recently announced to be coming to iOS in November, is now available to pre-order on the App Store. [Read more] | Read more »
    Presidents Run has returned for the 2020...
    IKIN's popular endless runner Presidents Run has returned to iOS and Android just in time for the 2020 election season. It will see players choosing their favourite candidate and guiding them on a literal run for presidency to gather as many votes... | Read more »
    New update for Cookies Must Die adds new...
    A new update for Rebel Twins’ platformer shooter Cookies Must Die is coming out this week. The update adds quite a bit to the game, including new levels and characters to play around with. [Read more] | Read more »
    Genshin Impact Guide - How to Beat Pyro...
    The end game of Genshin Impact largely revolves around spending resin to take on world bosses and clear domain challenges. These fights grant amazing rewards like rare artifacts and ascension materials for weapons and adventurers, but obviously... | Read more »
    Moto Rider GO has received a huge update...
    Moto Rider GO: Highway Traffic is a popular free-to-play racing game that initially launched back in 2017 and has since racked up over 100 million downloads. Today it has received a sizeable update that introduces several KTM and Husqvarna... | Read more »
    ORDESA is a spooky interactive film that...
    French studio Cinétévé Experience and ARTE have released interactive movie ORDESA for iOS and Android today. It arrives at the perfect time of year, telling a story about a mysterious haunted house that the viewer suddenly finds themselves lost in... | Read more »
    Genshin Impact Guide - How to Beat Storm...
    If you've followed our progression guide for Genshin Impact up to Adventure Rank 25, you have reached the point where you can face off against Stormterror on a weekly basis for some pretty sweet rewards. Beating this deadly dragon isn't as easy as... | Read more »
    MU Origin 2’s new update welcomes back l...
    MU Origin 2 developer Webzen continues to churn out new content for the popular MMORPG and, true to form, it’s just released another update. This one encourages lapsed players to return to the game with the promise of new quests and rewards. [... | Read more »
    Genshin Impact Guide - Everything you ne...
    Genshin Impact has unveiled its first of what we can expect to be many special events and ongoing content updates. This latest update adds the Elemental Crucible Event. This event is available to any players that have reached Adventure Rank 20,... | Read more »

    Price Scanner via MacPrices.net

    Apple has 2020 13″ MacBook Airs available sta...
    Apple has a full line of Certified Refurbished 2020 13″ MacBook Airs available starting at only $849 and up to $200 off the cost of new Airs. Each MacBook features a new outer case, comes with a... Read more
    These major wireless carriers will give you a...
    Apple’s wireless partners are offering several deals on iPhone 12 pre-orders right now. If you’re willing to switch carriers, you can get a free iPhone 12 right now. Here’s where to take advantage of... Read more
    4 day sale at Sams Club: Save $24-$29 on Appl...
    Sams Club has Apple Watch Series 6 GPS models on sale this week for $24-$29 off Apple’s MSRP, starting at $374. Sale ends this Thursday, October 22nd: – 40mm Apple Watch Series 6 GPS: $374.98, save $... Read more
    US Cellular offers Apple iPhone 12 Pro for $8...
    US Cellular has the 2020 128GB iPhone 12 Pro available for $829 off MSRP for new customers signing up for an Unlimited data plan, or $5.66 per month. Cost of the phone is spread over a 30 month... Read more
    Buy one Apple Watch SE or Series 6 at AT&...
    Buy one Apple Watch SE or Series 6 at AT&T, and get $200 off the price of a second Apple Watch. One new line required, and price discounted reflected in bill credits over a 30 month period. The... Read more
    AT&T offers free iPhone 12, $800 off iPho...
    AT&T is offering Apple’s new iPhone 12 for free, or up to $800 off the iPhone 12 Pro, for customers opening a new line of service plus an eligible trade-in. Discount is applied via monthly bill... Read more
    US Cellular offers free iPhone 12 for custome...
    US Cellular has the 2020 64GB iPhone 12 available for free for new customers signing up for an Unlimited data plan. Cost of the phone is spread over a 30 month period. The fine print: “Promotional... Read more
    New Xfinity Mobile promo: Take $250 off Apple...
    New customers opening a new line of service can take $250 off the purchase of Apple’s new iPhone 12 or iPhone 23 Pro at Xfinity Mobile through 1/4/21. Service plan required. Their offer reduces the... Read more
    New at Verizon: Get the Apple 2020 64GB iPhon...
    Verizon is offering the new 2020 64GB iPhone 12 for free for customers switching and opening a new line of service, pre-orders starting at October 16, 2020. They’re offering up to $800 off on 128GB... Read more
    Verizon offers the new iPhone 12 Pro for $800...
    Verizon is offering the new 2020 iPhone 12 Pro for $800 off MSRP for pre-orders, starting on October 16, 2020. Their offer reduces the price of the 128GB iPhone 12 Pro, for example, to only $199.99... Read more

    Jobs Board

    Department Manager- Tech Shop/ *Apple* Stor...
    …their parents want, and our faculty needs. As a Department Manager in our Tech Shop/ Apple Store you will spend the majority of your time on the sales floor engaging Read more
    Geek Squad *Apple* Consultation Professiona...
    **782284BR** **Job Title:** Geek Squad Apple Consultation Professional **Job Category:** Store Associates **Store Number or Department:** 000140-San Carlos-Store Read more
    *Apple* /Mac IT Support - Randstad (United St...
    Apple /Mac IT Support **job details:** + location:San Francisco, CA + salary:$45 - $50 per hour + date posted:Thursday, October 8, 2020 + job type:Contract + Read more
    Partner Champion, *Apple* - Insight Network...
    Partner Champion, Apple Tempe, AZ, US Requisition Number:78333 As an Apple Partner Champion at Insight, you represent and manage gross profit goals for a valued Read more
    Platform - Workplace Eng - *Apple* Enterpri...
    MORE ABOUT THIS JOB We are looking for an Apple Platform Engineer who will bring a unique engineering skill set, support, clarity, organization and above all else, Read more
    All contents are Copyright 1984-2011 by Xplain Corporation. All rights reserved. Theme designed by Icreon.