TweetFollow Us on Twitter

Oct 01 Cover Story

Volume Number: 17 (2001)
Issue Number: 10
Column Tag: Software Engineering

Frameworks

by Paul E. Sevinc, Switzerland

Introduction

Reuse is a key objective of software engineering. In our January 2001 article [15], we discussed how reuse is achieved by the use of patterns. To recap, we saw that patterns promote analysis, architecture, or design reuse, but never implementation reuse. A framework supplies the mechanisms that enforce a policy for interaction between software entities with open implementations [2]. As we shall see, frameworks always promote analysis, design, and implementation reuse, but not always architecture reuse.

In this article, we briefly review libraries and toolkits as a point of comparison for frameworks. Then we discuss in more detail object-oriented frameworks. Finally, we touch on the issue of black-box vs. white-box reuse.

Libraries and Toolkits

Szyperski [17, p. 134] notes that "[e]arly programming languages attempted to provide all functions that would ever be used in multiple programs. An explosion of built-in functions was the result. [...] Since then, there has been a clear tendency to take specific functionality out of languages, in favor of abstractional and structural features." The specific functionality that was taken out, as well as additional functionality, was put in libraries. (As explained at the end of this section, toolkits are just special types of libraries.) The evolution of Pascal over Modula-2 to Oberon [11] is but one witness of this tendency.

The primary purpose of software libraries is to provide software engineers with reusable pieces of code (i.e., implementation). The most common kinds of libraries are procedure libraries (also called function libraries) and class libraries.

The Mac Toolbox/Carbon [1] is an example of a procedure/function library. It is designed and implemented in a procedural fashion to be used with a procedural programming language such as Pascal or C. Note that it not only defines procedures/functions, but also data structures (i.e., RECORDs and structs).

The C++ Standard Library [16] is an example of a class library. It is designed and implemented in an object-oriented fashion to be used with an object-oriented programming language, namely C++. Just like C++ is not a purely object-oriented programming language (as opposed to Java for instance), but a hybrid programming language, the C++ Standard Library is not a pure class library. Rather, it is a library of libraries, some of which are class libraries.

Toolkits are simply class libraries whose classes are related [5]. An example is the Java Abstract Window Toolkit (AWT), a library of classes for graphical user interfaces (GUIs) [6].

Libraries vs. Frameworks

First of all, let us dispel a common misconception: frameworks are not exclusive to the realm of object orientation. Oberon microsystems, for instance, have an amazing component framework in their product line [10]. And numerous frameworks have been realized in a procedural programming language such as C. However, we have to add that in the latter case, procedure variables/function pointers are typically used to mimic polymorphism. That said, we nevertheless confine ourselves to object-oriented frameworks, nowadays the most typical kind of frameworks, in the next section.

Whatever the paradigm used, the key difference between libraries and frameworks lies in whether the client is in charge or not:


Figure 1: Library vs. Framework [9].

In procedural programming, the client of a procedure library develops the main procedure and calls library procedures at her own discretion (see Figure 1 left). In a similar manner, when using a class library, the user-defined classes are in control and determine the overall architecture of the system.

The opposite is the case when development is based on frameworks; the framework decides when the user's methods are invoked. Thus, there is an inversion of control; the framework incorporates the control logic [5, 12] (see Figure 1 right). (The way this is realized in object-oriented frameworks is explained in the next section.) This is called the Hollywood principle: "Don't call us, we'll call you!" [9] or the Greyhound principle: "Leave the driving to us." [2].

Examples: The Java Platform Math Class and Model-View-Controller in Swing

The Java Math class [6] defines mathematical functions (e.g., sin) as well constants (e.g., e) and as a whole is obviously a function library. Client code that invokes one of Math's methods relinquishes control only for a split second and does not have to worry about any side effects.

The Model-View-Controller (MVC) pattern [5, 9] depicted in Figure 2 underlies Java's Swing GUI elements [6]. In the case of a text field, for instance, the model manages the actual text in memory, the view displays the text on screen, and the controller determines the text's editability.


Figure 2: Components of the MVC [9].

We are not restricted to using the text field as is. Any of its three constituent parts can be replaced independent of the others by a subclass (e.g., the default controller in order to accept numerical characters only). That and the fact that the methods our subclass overrides are—or in a good design at least should be—invoked only by non-client code make the text field a framework.

Object-Oriented Frameworks

An object-oriented framework is a customizable implementation of software. It consists of a set of cooperating classes and has hot spots [9] (also called plug points [4]), which make the customization possible (see Figure 3).


Figure 3: Framework [9].

Hot spots are abstract, or at least non-final, classes. Through factory, template and hook methods [5], the framework invokes the methods on the subclasses of the hot spots (see Figure 4). But it maintains overall control and makes sure that certain core tasks are fulfilled.


Figure 4: HotSpot [9].

Example: JUnit

JUnit is a framework for unit testing in Java [7]. Its original authors are Kent Beck and Erich Gamma, but it is maintained by an open community of software engineers. JUnit's four core types are partially depicted in Figure 5.

Clients of the framework subclass TestCase to add one or more methods that actually conduct tests. That is, TestCase is a hot spot. The three TestCase methods shown in italic are not really abstract: setUp and tearDown are empty hook methods invoked by the template method run before and after runTest, respectively. And runTest's default implementation invokes the client-added test method designated by the fName field using reflection.


Figure 5: JUnit Extract (adapted from [3]).

Let us discuss the use of the fName field a little bit more. As we already mentioned, a TestCase subclass can define more than one test method to test different aspects of a class or a set of classes. Typically, runTest invokes only one client-added test method (because setUp and tearDown should be invoked before and after every test method, but only by run in order to keep the design clean). Therefore, the TestCase subclass has to be further subclassed to override runTest for each test method. Alternatively, the TestCase subclass is not subclassed further. Instead, fName is defined to contain the name of different test methods for different instances. The latter approach is obviously simpler (albeit less type safe). (Using reflection in this way within an object-oriented framework allows for what could be considered "run-time parameterizable hot-spots".)

Beck and Gamma [3] treat the core design of the JUnit framework (using the language of design patterns) in more detail.

Application and Domain-Specific Frameworks

Frameworks can be domain-specific. FEMO, for instance, is a framework for multiobjective optimization with genetic algorithms [13]. Applications that make use of FEMO relinquish control during optimization runs, but FEMO does not impose any architecture on the application as a whole. Therefore, FEMO promotes analysis, design, and implementation reuse: analysis of the domain, and design and implementation of the classes.

An application framework is a standard program that takes care of window management, menu handling, opening & saving documents, etc., but that has to be extended by the programmer to give them content. Mössenböck [9] calls this programming by difference. Metrowerks' PowerPlant [8] is a typical application framework and as such defines the overall architecture of every PowerPlant-based application.

Black-Box vs. White-Box Reuse

A black-box framework hides its implementation from its clients whereas the implementation of a white-box framework is visible to—and possibly modifiable by—its clients. A glass-box framework is a white-box framework whose implementation is not modifiable. [18] (Note that, rather confusingly, frameworks are sometimes designated as white-box as soon as they emphasize implementation inheritance over object composition [17], whether the implementation is actually visible to the client or not.)

Black-box reuse is preferable over white-box reuse. With the former, when (part of) the framework is replaced by a new release whose interface and specification have not changed, client code should not break. With the latter, the implementation may have to be studied anew, since at least informally it was part of the contract.

Listing 1

method( Type parameter )
   throws IllegalArgumentException
{
   if ( parameter == null || !inRange( parameter ) ) {
      throw new IllegalArgumentException();
   }
   ...
}

For example, after studying its source code, some clients of the white-box method method in Listing 1 might rely on NullPointerExceptions (which are unchecked exceptions in Java and thus need not be declared in the exception specification) never being thrown. In a future version, method no longer checks for null references (see Listing 2), which—let us assume—it never advertised to do anywhere in its formal documentation in the first place. At compile time, all of the existing clients will compile just fine. At run time, however, some might now behave erroneously.

Listing 2

method( Type parameter )
   throws IllegalArgumentException
{
   if ( !inRange( parameter ) ) {
      throw new IllegalArgumentException();
   }
   ...
}

To Probe Further

Mössenböck's Objektorientierte Programmierung in Oberon-2 [9] is an excellent book on object orientation in general. The latest edition features a chapter on frameworks. Unfortunately, this edition has never been translated to English.

Gamma et al.'s Design Patterns [5] is first and foremost a book on, well, design patterns. Nevertheless, it also quickly introduces frameworks and discusses the important relationship between patterns and frameworks.

Szyperski's Component Software [17] is a seminal work on component orientation. It features a chapter discussing reuse in general, including a concise treatment of frameworks.

Acknowledgments

This article is partly based on a chapter in my M.S. thesis [14] that was proofread and commented on by Prof. Dr. Rachid Guerraoui, Dr. Jean-Philippe Martin-Flatin, Luc Girardin, and Dani Seelhofer.

I would like to thank the contributing reviewers for this article, Nate Little and Peter "Primetime" Taylor from Trilogy Software, Inc.

References

  • [1] Apple Computer, Inc. Carbon Developer Documentation. Home Page. Located at
    http://developer.apple.com/techpubs/macosx/Carbon/carbon.html.
  • [2] B. Appleton. "Patterns and Software: Essential Concepts and Terminology". Available at
    http://www.enteract.com/~bradapp/docs/.
  • [3] K. Beck and E. Gamma. "JUnit: A Cook's Tour". Java Report, Vol. 4, No. 5, May 1999.
  • [4] D.F. D'Souza and A.C. Wills. Objects, Components, and Frameworks with UML: The Catalysis Approach. Addison-Wesley, Reading (Massachusetts), 1999.
  • [5] E. Gamma, R. Helm, R. Johnson, and J. Vlissides. Design Patterns: Elements of Reusable Object-Oriented Software. Addison-Wesley, Reading (Massachusetts), 1995.
  • [6] C.S. Horstmann and G. Cornell. Core Java: Fundamentals. Sun Microsystems Press, Palo Alto, 5th edition 2001.
  • [7] JUnit.org. JUnit, Testing Resources for Extreme Programming. Home Page. Located at
    http://www.junit.org/.
  • [8] A. Montgomery. "First Steps". MacTech Magazine, Vol. 17, No. 4, April 2001.
  • [9] H. Mössenböck. Objektorientierte Programmierung in Oberon-2. Springer, Heidelberg, 3rd edition 1998.
  • [10] Oberon microsystems, Inc. BlackBox Component Builder. Home Page. Located at
    http://www.oberon.ch/prod/BlackBox/index.html.
  • [11] M. Reiser and N. Wirth. Programming in Oberon: Steps beyond Pascal and Modula. Addison-Wesley, Reading (Massachusetts), 1992.
  • [12] S.R. Schoch. Classical and Object-Oriented Software Engineering: With UML and Java. McGraw-Hill, Boston, 4th edition 1999.
  • [13] P.E. Sevinç. Ein C++-Framework für die Mehrzieloptimierung mit genetischen Algorithmen. Semester Thesis, Swiss Federal Institute of Technology Zurich, January 1999.
  • [14] P.E. Sevinç. Design Patterns for the Management of IP Networks. M.S. Thesis, Swiss Federal Institute of Technology Zurich, February 2000.
  • [15] P.E. Sevinç. "Patterns". MacTech Magazine, Vol. 17, No. 1, January 2001.
  • [16] B. Stroustrup. The C++ Programming Language. Addison-Wesley, Reading (Massachusetts), 3rd edition 1997.
  • [17] C. Szyperski. Component Software: Beyond Object-Oriented Programming. Addison-Wesley, Reading (Massachusetts), 1998.
  • [18] C. Szyperski. "Components and Objects Together". Software Development, Vol. 7, No. 5, May 1999. Available at
    http://www.sdmagazine.com/breakrm/features/s995f2.shtml.

Paul E. Sevinç is back in Europe after spending three fantastic months in Austin, Texas going through Trilogy University, the corporate boot camp of Trilogy Software, Inc. You can reach him at paul.sevinc@ubilab.org.

 

Community Search:
MacTech Search:

Software Updates via MacUpdate

Bookends 13.2.5 - Reference management a...
Bookends is a full-featured bibliography/reference and information-management system for students and professionals. Bookends uses the cloud to sync reference libraries on all the Macs you use.... Read more
Quicken 2019 5.11.2 - Complete personal...
Quicken makes managing your money easier than ever. Whether paying bills, upgrading from Windows, enjoying more reliable downloads, or getting expert product help, Quicken's new and improved features... Read more
Dashlane 6.1927.0 - Password manager and...
Dashlane is an award-winning service that revolutionizes the online experience by replacing the drudgery of everyday transactional processes with convenient, automated simplicity - in other words,... Read more
Capo 3.7.4 - Slow down and learn to play...
Capo lets you slow down your favorite songs so you can hear the notes and learn how they are played. With Capo, you can quickly tab out your songs atop a highly-detailed OpenCL-powered spectrogram... Read more
BetterTouchTool 3.153 - Customize multi-...
BetterTouchTool adds many new, fully customizable gestures to the Magic Mouse, Multi-Touch MacBook trackpad, and Magic Trackpad. These gestures are customizable: Magic Mouse: Pinch in / out (zoom)... Read more
calibre 3.46.0 - Complete e-book library...
Calibre is a complete e-book library manager. Organize your collection, convert your books to multiple formats, and sync with all of your devices. Let Calibre be your multi-tasking digital librarian... Read more
Firefox 68.0.1 - Fast, safe Web browser.
Firefox offers a fast, safe Web browsing experience. Browse quickly, securely, and effortlessly. With its industry-leading features, Firefox is the choice of Web development professionals and casual... Read more
Vivaldi 2.6.1566.49 - An advanced browse...
Vivaldi is a browser for our friends. We live in our browsers. Choose one that has the features you need, a style that fits and values you can stand by. From the look and feel, to how you interact... Read more
Daylite 6.7.3.1 - Dynamic business organ...
Daylite helps businesses organize themselves with tools such as shared calendars, contacts, tasks, projects, notes, and more. Enable easy collaboration with features such as task and project... Read more
Vivaldi 2.6.1566.49 - An advanced browse...
Vivaldi is a browser for our friends. We live in our browsers. Choose one that has the features you need, a style that fits and values you can stand by. From the look and feel, to how you interact... Read more

Latest Forum Discussions

See All

Void Tyrant guide - Tips and tricks for...
Void Tyrant continues to get a lot of play in these parts. Probably because the game is just so deep and varied. The next stop on our guide series for Void Tyrant is class-specific guides. First up is the Knight, as it’s the first class anyone has... | Read more »
Summon beasts and battle evil in epic re...
Imagine a tale of conlict between factions of good and evil, where rogueish heroes summon beasts to aid them in them in warfare and courageously battle dragons over fields of scorched earth and brimstone - that's exactly the essence of epic fantasy... | Read more »
Upcoming visual novel Arranged shines a...
If you’re in the market for a new type of visual novel designed to inform and make you think deeply about its subject matter, then Arranged by Kabuk Games could be exactly what you’re looking for. It’s a wholly unique take on marital traditions in... | Read more »
TEPPEN guide - The three best decks in T...
TEPPEN’s unique take on the collectible card game genre is exciting. It’s just over a week old, but that isn’t stopping lots of folks from speculating about the long-term viability of the game, as well as changes and additions that will happen over... | Read more »
Intergalactic puzzler Silly Memory serve...
Recently released matching puzzler Silly Memory is helping its fans with their intergalactic journeys this month with some very special offers on in-app purchases. In case you missed it, Silly Memory is the debut title of French based indie... | Read more »
TEPPEN guide - Tips and tricks for new p...
TEPPEN is a wild game that nobody asked for, but I’m sure glad it exists. Who would’ve thought that a CCG featuring Capcom characters could be so cool and weird? In case you’re not completely sure what TEPPEN is, make sure to check out our review... | Read more »
Dr. Mario World guide - Other games that...
We now live in a post-Dr. Mario World world, and I gotta say, things don’t feel too different. Nintendo continues to squirt out bad games on phones, causing all but the most stalwart fans of mobile games to question why they even bother... | Read more »
Strategy RPG Brown Dust introduces its b...
Epic turn-based RPG Brown Dust is set to turn 500 days old next week, and to celebrate, Neowiz has just unveiled its biggest and most exciting update yet, offering a host of new rewards, increased gacha rates, and a brand new feature that will... | Read more »
Dr. Mario World is yet another disappoin...
As soon as I booted up Dr. Mario World, I knew I wasn’t going to have fun with it. Nintendo’s record on phones thus far has been pretty spotty, with things trending downward as of late. [Read more] | Read more »
Retro Space Shooter P.3 is now available...
Shoot-em-ups tend to be a dime a dozen on the App Store, but every so often you come across one gem that aims to shake up the genre in a unique way. Developer Devjgame’s P.3 is the latest game seeking to do so this, working as a love letter to the... | Read more »

Price Scanner via MacPrices.net

Flash sale! New 11″ 1TB WiFi iPad Pros for th...
Amazon has the 11″ 1TB WiFi iPad Pro on sale today for only $1199.99 including free shipping. Their price is $350 off Apple’s MSRP for this model, and it’s the lowest price ever for a 1TB 11″ iPad... Read more
Weekend Deal: 2018 13″ MacBook Airs starting...
B&H Photo has clearance 2018 13″ MacBook Airs available starting at only $999 with all models now available for $200 off Apple’s original MSRP. Overnight shipping, or expedited shipping, is free... Read more
Apple has clearance 10.5″ iPad Pros available...
Apple has Certified Refurbished 2017 10.5″ iPad Pros available starting at $469. An Apple one-year warranty is included with each iPad, outer shells are new, and shipping is free: – 64GB 10″ iPad Pro... Read more
Apple restocks refurbished iPad mini 4 models...
Apple has restocked Certified Refurbished 32GB iPad mini 4 WiFi models for $229 shipped. That’s $70 off original MSRP for the iPad mini 4. Space Gray, Silver, and Gold colors are available. Read more
Apple, Yet Again, Is Missing An Ultraportable...
EDITORIAL: 07.19.19 Prior to the decision made by Apple earlier this month to retire the thin and light MacBook model with a 12-inch retina display, the Cupertino, California-based company offered,... Read more
Verizon is offering a 50% discount on iPhone...
Verizon is offering 50% discounts on Apple iPhone 8 and iPhone 8 Plus models though July 24th, plus save 50% on activation fees. New line required. The fine print: “New device payment & new... Read more
Get a new 21″ iMac for under $1000 today at t...
B&H Photo has new 21″ Apple iMacs on sale for up to $100 off MSRP with models available starting at $999. These are the same iMacs offered by Apple in their retail and online stores. Shipping is... Read more
Clearance 2017 15″ 2.8GHz Touch Bar MacBook P...
Apple has Certified Refurbished 2017 15″ 2.8GHz Space Gray Touch Bar MacBook Pros available for $1809. Apple’s refurbished price is currently the lowest available for a 15″ MacBook Pro. An standard... Read more
Clearance 12″ 1.2GHz MacBook on sale for $899...
Focus Camera has clearance 12″ 1.2GHz Space Gray MacBooks available for $899.99 shipped. That’s $400 off Apple’s original MSRP. Focus charges sales tax for NY & NJ residents only. Read more
Get a new 2019 13″ 2.4GHz 4-Core MacBook Pro...
B&H Photo has new 2019 13″ 2.4GHz MacBook Pros on sale for up to $150 off Apple’s MSRP. Overnight shipping is free to many addresses in the US: – 2019 13″ 2.4GHz/256GB 6-Core MacBook Pro Silver... Read more

Jobs Board

Best Buy *Apple* Computing Master - Best Bu...
**707083BR** **Job Title:** Best Buy Apple Computing Master **Job Category:** Sales **Location Number:** 000045-Rockford-Store **Job Description:** **What does a Read more
Geek Squad *Apple* Master Consultation Agen...
**702908BR** **Job Title:** Geek Squad Apple Master Consultation Agent **Job Category:** Services/Installation/Repair **Location Number:** 000360-Williston-Store Read more
Best Buy *Apple* Computing Master - Best Bu...
**711023BR** **Job Title:** Best Buy Apple Computing Master **Job Category:** Sales **Location Number:** 000012-St Cloud-Store **Job Description:** **What does a Read more
*Apple* Systems Architect/Engineer, Vice Pre...
…its vision to be the world's most trusted financial group. **Summary:** Apple Systems Architect/Engineer with strong knowledge of products and services related to Read more
Best Buy *Apple* Computing Master - Best Bu...
**696259BR** **Job Title:** Best Buy Apple Computing Master **Job Category:** Store Associates **Location Number:** 001076-Temecula-Store **Job Description:** The Read more
All contents are Copyright 1984-2011 by Xplain Corporation. All rights reserved. Theme designed by Icreon.