TweetFollow Us on Twitter

Safe Haquery Volume Number: 17 (2001)
Issue Number: 2
Column Tag: Mac OS X

The Art of Safe Haquery, Categorically Speaking

By Andrew Stone

The Subtitle in Italics

The Cocoa newcomer is constantly barraged with enthusiasm and praise of the Cocoa APIs by the early Cocoa adopters. These lofty feelings are indeed merited by the powerful and easy to use Cocoa development environment. Although Cocoa comes in both Java and Objective-C flavors, it's Objective-C which shines for ease of adding new functionality to existing classes through the Objective-C language mechanism known as Categories. This article will show you how to add and change functionality of an existing Cocoa class, the NSSavePanel, by using a category, a subclass and a tool which reveals all the methods in a class, classdump.

First, I must explain the spelling of haque and haquery, and how that came to be. In the field of Computer Science, we lovingly refer to the art of clever programming as hacking. But alas, the free press (albeit, controlled by only 5 men) has taken to using the term "hacker" for people engaged in unlawful computer cracking. Take back our term! By adding a slightly continental twist, voilà, le haque!

Before we embark on how to go below the API to accomplish tasks unaccomplishable through normal means, I am required by the unwritten laws of the unformed guild of responsible programmers to give my short lecture on using undocumented, unexposed API: Don't do it - you'll regret it - your program will break in a future release. The lecture always sounds better in the positive: if you strictly adhere to the Cocoa API, then not only will your application continue to function in future releases, it will actually run better as the dynamically loaded frameworks it depends on receive bug fixes from Apple.

That said, when you've decided that the only way to obtain behavior you desire is by using undocumented API, you need to make that code as safe as possible by assuming that the Apple implementation will change underneath you. We'll go over the tricks and tips when we look at the code below.

First, I wanted the ability to let the user create a new directory in a preset folder. I wanted to reuse the NSSavePanel because it knows how to get the name of a new directory and run as a sheet, Cocoa style. But the SavePanel is designed to allow the user to browse the directory structure and I don't want to allow that. When the SavePanel is in its "minimum" state with the File browser hidden, it's almost perfect for my needs. By disabling both the "reveal the browser" button and the Favorites popup, the panel is perfect for my needs:


Figure 1. This save panel has been tweaked to allow the user to create a new folder in the current folder only - there is no way for the user to navigate to other folders.

Unfortunately, there is no API to make the SavePanel not display the browser, New Folder button, Favorites popup, and other interface items which allow the user to leave the directory explicitly set by the program. So - how the heck can one programmatically shrink up the save panel? The best place to start looking is inside the NSSavePanel.nib file - which lives in /System/Library/Frameworks/AppKit.framework/Resources/English.lproj. Double-click that file to launch InterfaceBuilder.

We notice that the UI objects we need to mess with have outlets in the NSSavePanel class:

  • _favoritesPopup is the popup we need to disable
  • _expandButton is the button which makes the browser come and go

We also note that the expandButton's target is the SavePanel, and its action is: _expandPanel:. Right away, the leading underscore tips us off that this is an undocumented method. We do not want to call this directly; its name may change. Here's the trick: simply ask the expandButton to performClick:! That way, should Apple change the method which that button sends, our code will still work correctly. We are only in trouble if they remove _expandButton or change its name. Further safety could be had by noting the tag of the _expandButton in InterfaceBuilder, and using NSView's "viewWithTag" to find the button - thus never referring to the button by name. However, the creator of the nib file didn't assign a tag to either the expand button or the favorites popup, so that technique is useless here. You could also do a recursive search of the panel's contentView's subviews for a view of class NSPopUpButton to find the _favoritesPopup, but that would break if Apple added another popup to the panel.

Now, open the header file for NSSavePanel, found in:

/System/Library/Frameworks/AppKit.framework//Headers/NSSavePanel.h

You'll see the whole API - but here's what's interesting for us:

@interface NSSavePanel : NSPanel
{
    /*All instance variables are private*/
// Apple is telling you NOT TO RELY ON ANYTHING HERE!

    NSBrowser      *_browser;
    ...
    id                  _expandButton;
    ...
    id                  _favoritesPopup;
    ...
    struct __spFlags {
    ...
        unsigned int       collapsed:1;
    ...
    }                   _spFlags;
    ...
}

So, it looks like there is a way to determine if the panel is collapsed (_spFlags.collapsed), and we can disable the favorites button (_favoritesPopup) as well as ask the expandButton (_expandButton) to pretend the user clicked it.

We'll write a simple method to use in our application which checks the collapsed state of the panel, collapses it if it is expanded, and disables the folder navigation buttons. Because we're adding functionality and don't need to change any existing NSSavePanel methods, we'll use a category.

A category looks similar to class implementations, except:

  1. a category name comes after the class name
  2. no new instance variables can be declared

Here's our interface declaration:

@interface NSSavePanel(SuperTrickyStuff)
- (void)prepareToDisplayOnlyName;
@end

So a client of our SavePanel, who wants the collapsed version, will use calling code similar to this:

- (IBAction)newGalleryAction:(id)sender {

  // save panel configured for only creating new folders in the current one
  // Because we mess with this panel, we want our own copy so this doesn't
  // affect normal save panels used in the rest of the application:

    static NSSavePanel *savepanel = nil;
    if (!savepanel) {
        // If the save panel is to be reused, you must retain it!
        savepanel = [[NSSavePanel savePanel]retain];
    }
   // establish the folder where you want users to create a new folder:
   // note how subclasses could redefine where the saveDirectory is:
    [savepanel setDirectory:[self saveDirectory]];

   // Make the savepanel not require a filetype
   //  (directories don't require a path extension)
    [savepanel setRequiredFileType:@""];
    
    // Here's our invocation of our new category method
    // see explanation below as to why we use performSelector:withObject:afterDelay:
    [savepanel performSelector:@selector(prepareToDisplayOnlyName) withObject:nil afterDelay:.01];

   // following the Cocoa model of running save sheets, use NSSavePanel's
   // new API to run the save panel window modally:
   // This establishes the callback method, delegate, and context information
  // for use when, and if, the user ever finishes running the save panel:

    [savepanel beginSheetForDirectory:[self saveDirectory] file:@""
modalForWindow:[_controller window] modalDelegate:self
didEndSelector:@selector(didEndGallerySheet:returnCode:contextInfo:) contextInfo:NULL];

}

The only tricky part about calling our new category method is that we want it to happen AFTER the window has already come up on screen. And since the call to beginSheetForDirectory:file:modalForWindow:modalDelegate:didEndSelector: returns immediately, we need to schedule our call to prepareToDisplayOnlyName to occur AFTER the sheet appears on the window. Ideally you would do it before the window comes up so the user won't see the window collapse before her eyes - but it turns out that the Save panel does its own setting of the collapsed state if the user last collapsed another Save panel in the application. Once the save panel is displayed, then the programmatic "clicking" of the expand button will work correctly. NSObject defines a method, performSelector:withObject:afterDelay: for times when you need to schedule a call to happen after the current event loop goes around. If I tried to collapse it too early, it would further collapse and disappear!

Our implemenation of our Save panel category is also very straighforward - 8 lines of code:

@implementation NSSavePanel(SuperTrickyStuff)

// the user must be unable to use the Favorites popup 
// and the expand button, so we disable them:

- (void)disableButtons {
   [_favoritesPopup setEnabled:NO];
   [_expandButton setEnabled:NO];
}

// we temporarily enable the expand button just so we can send it the method
// performClick:

- (void)collapse:(id)sender {
   [_expandButton setEnabled:YES];
   [_expandButton performClick:nil];
   [self disableButtons];
}

// this is the only method we expose - and 
// all you need to call to set up the panel:

- (void)prepareToDisplayOnlyName {
    if (!_spFlags.collapsed) {
        [self collapse:nil];
    } else [self disableButtons];  
   // if it's already collapsed, we want the buttons disabled
}

Note that we need to call this every time we run the panel, because if the user sets another SavePanel into full file browser mode, the next time we run our save panel, it will once again try to set itself to the expanded state because of the inner workings of the NSSavePanel.

My next SavePanel challenge arose when the behavior of NSSavePanel changed for the worse in Public Beta. Now, when you go to save a file, all existing files are "disabled" and dimmed, so it's very hard to overwrite an existing file - you have to painstakingly and correctly type the exact name of the preexisting file. It used to be that you could simply double-click an existing file to save over it, and that behavior is what we want to restore to the panel. When outputting HTML, users may tweak something and then want to output the new version to a preexisting directory, essentially writing over the previous files. Since users complained about the apparent inability to write over old files, I decided it was time to peer deeper into the API.


Figure 2. This save panel has been tweaked to allow the user to select existing files - normally, they are disabled and unselectable.

After finding no available API to do what I wanted, I approached this by researching the private methods of NSSavePanel to try and deduce how this enabling/disabling was occurring. A piece of perennial software that has been companion to NeXTStep and OpenStep developers for years is now available for Cocoa: class-dump. This command line tool takes advantage of the Objective-C runtime to spit out all the instance and class methods in a program, bundle or framework. My friends at www.stepwise.com have a version via SoftTrak updated for OS X by James McIlrae: http://www.stepwise.com/SoftTrak/ and search for "class-dump". Once again, let me repeat that any developer who uses undocumented API deserves the headaches thus incurred! By using class-dump on the AppKit framework and searching for NSSavePanel, I found two methods that seemed extremely related to what I was trying to do:

- _itemHit:fp12;
- (BOOL)_enableLeaf:(id)fp12 container:(id)fp16 {

Moreover, from the nib file, I learned that the filename field is actually an NSForm. I also guessed correctly that the browser sends the method _itemHit: to the NSSavePanel when you click an item in the browser. To do what we want to do, we need to change _itemHit. Because we have absolutely no idea what the original implementation of _itemHit: is, we need to be able to call the original implementation. Because of this, we can't use a category, which would hide the original implementation. Instead, we create a subclass of NSSavePanel, SaveOverPanel, which allows us to call super's implementation to get the real work done, and then afterwards, monkey with the UI to obtain the behavior we desire.

How can we be safe in this instance? First off, our implementation is totally passive. By passive, I mean we are not assuming that NSSavePanel will respond to any undocumented method. Instead, if and only if the NSSavePanel calls _itemHit:, we call super to let the panel do the work. If Apple takes out this method, our subclass's implementation will not get called. Moreover, we'll test each of our UI elements to see if they are still the same class using isKindOfClass:. If their class changes, our code will simply call super's implementation. So all we really need to do is return YES for whether any particular node is enabled, and then when a user clicks on an item, transfer that string to the filename field.

// define a subclass of NSSavePanel with no new instance variables:
@interface SaveOverPanel : NSSavePanel

@end

// reveal the secret method so the compiler will not complain:
@interface NSSavePanel(superSecret)
- _itemHit:fp12;
@end

// the few lines of code needed to do what we want:

@implementation SaveOverPanel

- (BOOL)_enableLeaf:(id)fp12 container:(id)fp16 {
   // we want every cell to be enabled:
   // should Apple take out this method, then it will never be called
   // and our program continues to work, but without our new functionality
   return YES;
}

// the NSBrowser is the sender:
- _itemHit:fp12 {
    // first be absolutely sure we know what kinds of objects we think we have:
    if ([fp12 isKindOfClass:[NSBrowser class]] && [_form isKindOfClass:[NSForm class]]) {
        NSBrowserCell *cell = [fp12 selectedCell];

        // by calling super, we insure any internal work is done right:
        id returnValue = [super _itemHit:fp12];

        // if we have a leaf node, ie file, transfer that to filename field:
        if ([cell isLeaf]) [[_form cellAtIndex:0] setStringValue:[cell stringValue]];

        // return what we got back from super, whatever it is ;-) :
        return returnValue;
    } else return [super _itemHit:fp12];
}

@end

To use this type of Savepanel, just include the new class when you create the panel:

- (IBAction)createWebPagesAction:(id)sender {
        static SaveOverPanel * savepanel = nil;
        if (!savepanel)  {
            savepanel = [[SaveOverPanel savePanel]retain];
        }
        ...
}

Conclusion

There are many good programming practices, but using undocumented API is not one of them! However, if your users demand certain functionality and no exposed API exists for that functionality, you might want to tread this dangerous ground. If you apply certain preventative techniques to your haquery, you can minimize side effects and future problems.


Andrew Stone, <andrew@stone.com>, is Chief Executive Haquer of Stone Design Corp - a New Mexican software house in its 13th year of producing Cocoa software.

 

Community Search:
MacTech Search:

Software Updates via MacUpdate

iShowU Instant 1.3.3 - Full-featured scr...
iShowU Instant gives you real-time screen recording like you've never seen before! It is the fastest, most feature-filled real-time screen capture tool from shinywhitebox yet. All of the features you... Read more
Affinity Photo 1.8.3 - Digital editing f...
Affinity Photo - redefines the boundaries for professional photo editing software for the Mac. With a meticulous focus on workflow it offers sophisticated tools for enhancing, editing and retouching... Read more
Affinity Designer 1.8.3 - Vector graphic...
Affinity Designer is an incredibly accurate vector illustrator that feels fast and at home in the hands of creative professionals. It intuitively combines rock solid and crisp vector art with... Read more
Pinegrow 5.95 - Mockup and design web pa...
Pinegrow (was Pinegrow Web Designer) is desktop app that lets you mockup and design webpages faster with multi-page editing, CSS and LESS styling, and smart components for Bootstrap, Foundation,... Read more
WhatRoute 2.3.1 - Geographically trace o...
WhatRoute is designed to find the names of all the routers an IP packet passes through on its way from your Mac to a destination host. It also measures the round-trip time from your Mac to the router... Read more
Dropbox 94.4.384 - Cloud backup and sync...
Dropbox for Mac is a file hosting service that provides cloud storage, file synchronization, personal cloud, and client software. It is a modern workspace that allows you to get to all of your files... Read more
Boom 3D 1.3.6 - $19.99
Boom 3D is a revolutionary app with 3D Surround Sound and phenomenally rich and intense audio that is realistic and works on any headphones. Features 3D surround sound Built-in audio player... Read more
Remotix 6.1.4 - Access all your computer...
Remotix is a fast and powerful application to easily access multiple Macs (and PCs) from your own Mac. Features: Complete Apple Screen Sharing support - including Mac OS X login, clipboard... Read more
iMazing 2.11.4 - Complete iOS device man...
iMazing (was DiskAid) is the ultimate iOS device manager with capabilities far beyond what iTunes offers. With iMazing and your iOS device (iPhone, iPad, or iPod), you can: Copy music to and from... Read more
EtreCheck Pro 6.2.4 - For troubleshootin...
EtreCheck is an app that displays the important details of your system configuration and allow you to copy that information to the Clipboard. It is meant to be used with Apple Support Communities to... Read more

Latest Forum Discussions

See All

Hearthstone's new Demon Class is no...
A couple of weeks ago Blizzard announced that the game would be introducing its first new class since the game first launched in 2014. It's called the Demon Hunter and as of today, players will be able to get a glimpse and feel for how it will... | Read more »
The 5 Best Games Like Dark Souls
There's no escaping the fact that everyone loves Dark Souls. If you've not heard of it, it's a super tough action RPG that punished your every mistake with swift retribution. It's the sort of game where you die a lot, and it can be pretty... | Read more »
The Curse of Issyos is a retro-inspired...
The Curse of Issyos is the latest game to be ported to mobile and published by Abylight S.L who previously worked on Cursed Castilla. Much like that port, this game was also originally created by Spanish developers Locomalito. The Curse of Issyos... | Read more »
Same Room Games is a great collection of...
Staying at home under lockdown kinda sucks. Totally necessary, yes, but also more than a little anxiety-inducing and often boring. Thankfully, we've got lots of great multiplayer games to play with friends and keep us sane, the latest of which,... | Read more »
Bark Park is a joyfully silly multiplaye...
Bark Park is a charming, good-humoured game about competing against other players to claim as much territory as possible by peeing on nearby trees. Did I mention that everyone is playing as a dog? Makes things a little less weird. [Read more] | Read more »
The 5 Best Games Like Grindstone
Apple Arcade made a splash when it first launched, granting access to over 50 games as soon as it became available. Of those titles, the one that seemed to grab most people’s attention was Grindstone, a matching puzzle game from Capy Games. [Read... | Read more »
Awarding-winning puzzler Make One is now...
Make One is a game with a simple concept that it executes with flair and impressive levels of polish. It comes to us from developer Brazle and publisher PiG, and it's just landed this week for Android. At its core, Make One is a logic-based... | Read more »
Marvel Contest of Champions' latest...
Kabam's Marvel Contest of Champions has now teased some of the latest characters heading to the Battlerealm next month. Here's your chance to watch the new motion comic embedded below, Barons' War, before I spoil the surprise. [Read more] | Read more »
Why Calibria: Crystal Guardians is the p...
We could all use escapism right now, something to focus on and a project to feel part of during these times of social isolation. If you’re one of the many who’s turned to gaming to fill the lockdown void, Calibria: Crystal Guardians should be on... | Read more »
Mini Tank: Fire is a Worms-like, turn-ba...
Mini Tank: Fire is an online multiplayer game that takes a few cues from the likes of Worms and Shell Shock Live. It will feature 5v5 turn-based battles and is available now for both iOS and Android as a free-to-play game. [Read more] | Read more »

Price Scanner via MacPrices.net

Clearance 13″ 128GB MacBook Air in stock toda...
Guitar Center has clearance 2019 13″ 1.6GHz/128GB Space Gray MacBook Airs in stock today for $899 shipped. That’s $200 off Apple’s original MSRP for this model and the cheapest price available today... Read more
Weekend sale: 21″ & 27″ iMacs for up to $...
B&H Photo has new 21″ and 27″ 5K iMacs in stock today and on sale for up to $200 off Apple’s MSRP. These are the same iMacs sold by Apple in their retail and online stores, and B&H’s prices... Read more
Here’s how you can save $50 today on one of A...
– 11″ 128GB WiFi iPad Pro: $789 $10 off – 11″ 256GB WiFi iPad Pro: $849 $50 off – 11″ 512GB WiFi iPad Pro: $1049 $50 off – 11″ 1TB WiFi iPad Pro: $1249.99 $50 off – 11″ 128GB WiFi + Cell iPad Pro: $... Read more
Apple AirPods Pro back on sale at Amazon for...
Amazon has Apple’s AirPods Pro in stock and on sale today for $234.98 shipped. Their price is about $15 (6%) off Apple’s MSRP and the cheapest price available for these new models from any Apple... Read more
Apple restocks clearance, previous-generation...
Apple has clearance, Certified Refurbished, 2019 13″ MacBook Airs available for only $779. Each MacBook features a new outer case, comes with a standard Apple one-year warranty, and is shipped free.... Read more
Retro Reading: PowerBook Central Coverage of...
FEATURE: 04.03.20- Welcome to another edition of “Retro Reading,” a series here in my column, “Mac Potpourri,” where we dig deep into the archives for content written on today’s date several years... Read more
Price drop! 21″ 3.6GHz Quad-Core 4K iMac on s...
B&H Photo has the 21″ 3.6GHz Quad-Core 4K iMac in stock today and on sale for $1099.99 including free next day shipping to many locations in the US. That’s $200 off Apple’s MSRP: – 21″ 3.6GHz... Read more
Amazon is again offering $129 Apple AirPods,...
Amazon has Apple AirPods with Charging Case on sale again for $129.98 shipped. Their price is $30 off Apple’s MSRP for these AirPods. Their price is the cheapest available for AirPods from any Apple... Read more
Apple continues to offer iMac discounts rangi...
Apple has Certified Refurbished 2019 21″ & 27″ iMacs available starting at $929 and up to $350 off the cost of new models. Apple’s one-year warranty is standard, shipping is free, and each iMac... Read more
Apple offers Certified Refurbished iPhone XS...
Apple has Certified Refurbished iPhone XS models available for up to $350 off MSRP, with prices starting at $699. Each iPhone is unlocked and comes with Apple’s standard one-year warranty and a new... Read more

Jobs Board

Tier II Support Specialist- *Apple* - KeenL...
…will be responsible for Desktop Support of an environment composed of Apple workstations and several custom business applications. Job Responsibilities: + Providing Read more
Sephora Merchandise/Operations Supervisor -...
Sephora Merchandise/Operations Supervisor - Apple Blossom Mall Location:Winchester, VA, United States- Apple Blossom Mall 1850 Apple Blossom Dr Job Read more
Sales Supervisor - *Apple* Blossom Mall - J...
Sales Supervisor - Apple Blossom Mall Location:Winchester, VA, United States- Apple Blossom Mall 1850 Apple Blossom Dr Job ID:1083621Store Hourly Positions Read more
*Apple* Mac Product Engineer - Barclays (Uni...
Apple Mac Engineer Whippany, NJ Support the development and delivery of solutions, products, and capabilities into the Barclays environment working across technical Read more
Essbase Developer - *Apple* - Theorem, LLC...
Job Summary Apple is seeking an experienced, detail-minded Essbase developer to join our worldwide business development and strategy team. If you are someone who Read more
All contents are Copyright 1984-2011 by Xplain Corporation. All rights reserved. Theme designed by Icreon.