TweetFollow Us on Twitter

Jan 97 Challenge

Volume Number: 13 (1997)
Issue Number: 1
Column Tag: Programmer's Challenge

Programmer's Challenge

By Bob Boonstra, Westford, MA


The theme of this issue of the magazine is the Be Operating System, so it seemed appropriate to focus the Challenge on the BeOS, and give you a chance to use the BeOS for Macintosh CD-ROM bundled in this issue. Since the BeOS will be new to most of you, this Challenge will be a simple one. The problem is to write a window class that will display and sort a list of strings by one of three specified methods: a bubble sort, an exchange sort, and an algorithm of your choosing. The prototype for the class you should write is

typedef enum SortType {
 kBubbleSort = 1,
 kExchangeSort = 2,
 kMySort = 3
} SortType;

class SortWindow : public BWindow {

 SortWindow(BRect frame); 
virtual void   DoSort(
 char *thingsToSort[],  /* list of strings to sort, also returns sorted list */
 int numberOfThings, /* number of thingsToSort */
 SortType sortMethod);  /* sort method to use */

My test code will open three instances of your window class and ask each one to sort a copy of the same list of strings: one by the kBubbleSort method, one by kExchangeSort, and one by kMySort. Your SortWindow constructor should create a BListView and attach it to your SortWindow. When the DoSort method is invoked, you should display the thingsToSort and sort them into ascending ASCII order by the sortMethod algorithm. Each time two thingsToSort are exchanged, the BListView display should be updated. When the sort is complete, DoSort should post a B_QUIT_REQUESTED message to the application. The list should be sorted in place and returned in thingsToSort.

This will be a native PowerPC Challenge, using the latest Macintosh CodeWarrior environment, targeted for the BeOS. Solutions must be coded in C++. The code will be tested on my 8500 using the BeOS. (In the event I cannot get the BeOS to run on my Mac, I will run the tests on a 2x133MHz BeBox with one processor disabled.) The winner will be the solution that completes all three sorts correctly in the minimum time.

Three Months Ago Winner

Congratulations to Andy Antoniewicz (Mountain View, CA) for narrowly beating second and third place finishers Greg Cooper and Ludovic Nicolle in the October DNA Match Challenge. Of the fifteen entries I received for this Challenge, ten worked completely correctly, two were partially correct, and the remaining three crashed my machine.

Recall that the DNA Match Challenge was essentially a string matching problem, where the strings were allowed to differ in a specified number of positions (or fewer). The object was to return the number of near matches of a fragment string found in a reference database string.

My intent had been to test the solutions submitted using very long database strings. The run times of the solutions imposed a practical limit of about 2 MB on the size of the database string in an individual test case. The fragments to be matched were all significantly shorter than the database string, as indicated in the problem statement. The tests ranged from requiring very accurate matches, with a small value for the number of differences allowed, to approximate matches that could differ in up to half of the characters in the reference string.

The problem statement allowed for a timed initialization routine that would be executed once prior to testing matches against multiple fragments for a given database string. None of the top-ranked solutions made any significant use of this option, although a number of people used it to initialize small translation tables. Several people commented that it was difficult to find a use for this initialization routine, when the scratch storage provided was smaller than the maximum size database string.

Andy's winning entry parses the fragment string to create, for each character in the DNA "alphabet", a list of offsets where that character is located in the fragment. He then walks the database string and increments a match counter for each possible alignment of the fragment that matches the database at that character position. Andy uses a circular buffer twice the size of the fragment to store the match counts, which allows him to perform bounds checking on that buffer only once per database character, rather than within the innermost character matching loop. I had to read the code several times and run through a few cases manually before the light went on and I understood the algorithm, after which I found it quite clever.

While A.C.C. Murphy's solution did not place in the top five, one of his algorithms used a refinement worthy of note. He kept a running total of the counts of characters in a fragment-sized segment of the database, only checking for a specific match if the frequency counts were close enough to those of the fragment. In test cases where the character frequencies of the fragment were significantly different than much of the database, this technique might have done very well.

The table below summarizes the results for each correct or partially correct entry, including total execution time for all of the test cases and code size. Numbers in parenthesis after a person's name indicate that person's cumulative point total for all previous Challenges, not including this one. An asterisk indicates a result that was partially correct and therefore not eligible to win.

NameLanguageTotal TimeCode Size
Andy Antoniewicz (4)C123823728
Greg Cooper (17)C126233872
Ludovic Nicolle (14)C126646528
Michael Panchenko (6)C148243800
Bjorn Davidsson (4)C149171424
A.C.C. Murphy (10)C1510861800
Ernst Munter (224)C++176521752
Peter Lewis (32)C195312240
Mark DayC197385848
Larry Landry (29)C2671181376
Alan Hart (*)C210701848
Xin Xu (*)C2230151576


Here are the Top 20 Contestants for the Programmer's Challenge. The numbers below include points awarded over the 24 most recent contests, including points earned by this month's entrants.

1.Munter, Ernst193
2.Gregg, Xan114
3.Larsson, Gustav87
4.Lengyel, Eric40
5.[Name deleted]40
6.Lewis, Peter32
7.Boring, Randy27
8.Cooper, Greg27
9.Antoniewicz, Andy24
10.Beith, Gary24
11.Kasparian, Raffi22
12.Cutts, Kevin21
13.Nicolle, Ludovic21
14.Picao, Miguel Cruz21
15.Brown, Jorg20
16.Gundrum, Eric20
17.Karsh, Bill19
18.Stenger, Allen19
19.Mallett, Jeff17
20.Nevard, John17

There are three ways to earn points: (1) scoring in the top 5 of any Challenge, (2) being the first person to find a bug in a published winning solution or, (3) being the first person to suggest a Challenge that I use. The points you can win are:

1st place20 points
2nd place10 points
3rd place7 points
4th place4 points
5th place2 points
finding bug2 points
suggesting Challenge2 points

Here is Andy's winning solution:


© 1996 Andy Antoniewicz

DNA string match with wildcard & constant distance

No setup calculations on the database are performed. It seemed kind of pointless to attempt the equivalent 
of a 50 to 1 loss, less compression of the database ( it was 1000 to 1 for the first problem statement ).

This is a simple and quick single byte per pass index and count type algorithm. It uses three tables: a byte 
to code index table "aTable", a fragment index list array "alphaList",
and a hit count circular array "matchQueue". A precursor list is built and used once to build the alphaList 
array, and I do not clean up after (plenty of allocated storage).
Once built, the aTable contains an index into the alphaList for each given alphabet letter in the fragment. 
The alphaList contains a sequential list of all occurrences of that character in the fragment string.

The algorithm then increments the match count for all possible alignments of the fragment for each database 
character. Since the maximum misalignment is less than the fragment size, only the previous fragmentSize 
database characters need to be considered for matches at any particular time. Hence the circular queue 

The database search execution time is order( pN ) where N = number of database characters
p = average fragment entries per alphabet char 
( for example: A=3,C=3,G=2,T=2 -
> p = 2.5 )
The storage used is almost totally dependent on the fragment size. Storage used in bytes
    = 20     ( storage struct )
    + 256         ( 16bit aTable )
    + 2 * fragment chars( 16bit precursor )
    + 2 * fragment chars( 16bit alphaList )
    + 2 * alphabet chars (  more alphaList )
    + 4 * fragment chars( 2x16bit matchQueue )

 ********* ********* ********* ********* ********* ********/
#define kAlphaTableSize   128
#define kEndOfAlphaList   -1
typedef struct {
 long storageSize; // total storage available
 long usedStorage; // total storage used
 long fragmentSize;// size in chars of fragment
 short  *alphaList;// start of fragment index list
 short  *matchQueue; // start of match count queue
 short  alphaTable[ kAlphaTableSize ];
 short  precursor[]; // start of match count queue
} DNAStore;

/********* ********* ********* ********* ********* ********
 Function Prototypes
 ********* ********* ********* ********* ********* ********/

void InitMatch(
 char *alphabet, // legal characters in database
 char *database, // the reference database
 void *storage,  // pre-allocated storage
 long storageSize// size of storage in bytes

long FindMatch(  // return number of matches
 char *alphabet, // legal characters in database
 char *database, // the reference database
 void *storage,  // pre-allocated storage
 char *fragment, // the fragment to find
 long diffsAllowed,// num of diffs allowed between
    //  a "match" and the database
 long matchPosition[]// match return array

void BuildAlphaList(
 char   *alphabet, // legal characters in database
 char   *fragment, // the fragment to find; 0 term
 DNAStore *storage // my storage area

/********* ********* ********* ********* ********* ********
 * InitMatch
 * This routine does nothing except to store the
 *  size of memory allocated by the calling program.
 * All of the structures used are based on the fragment
 * to be searched for.
 ********* ********* ********* ********* ********* ********/

void InitMatch(
 char *alphabet, // legal characters in database
 char *database, // the reference database
 void *storage,  // pre-allocated storage
 long storageSize// size of storage in bytes
 ((DNAStore*)storage)->storageSize = storageSize;
}// end of InitMatch

/********* ********* ********* ********* ********* ********
 * BuildAlphaList
 * This routine has three parts:
 * Build the AlphaTable
 * The AlphaTable is an index table used to find
 * the start location inside the AlphaList
 * that corresponds to the given alphabet
 * character.
 * Build the AlphaList precursor
 * This is a linked list of the indexes to each
 * character in the fragment. It is used once
 * to build the AlphaList and never re-used.
 * Build the AlphaList
 * This is a sorted list of indexes for each
 * alphabet character. The head of each list is
 * stored in the AlphaTable, and each list is
 * ended by a -1.
 ********* ********* ********* ********* ********* ********/

void BuildAlphaList(
 char   *alphabet, // legal characters in database
 char   *fragment, // the fragment to find; 0 term
 DNAStore *storage // my storage area
 short  *aTable; // ptr in the AlphaTable
 short  *precursor;// the AlphaList precursor
 short  *alphaList;// the AlphaList

 char *aString;  // ptr to a character string
 long aChar;// a character from a string
 long count;
 short  index;

     * Initialize alphabet entries to kEndOfAlphaList
     *     Proper function for characters not in the alphabet
     *     requires that the other entries be preset to zero.
     *     This is automatic if the storage is cleared by
     *     the calling program and if the alphabet does not
     *     change between calls to InitMatch.
 aTable = storage->alphaTable;
 aString = alphabet - 1;
 while( (aChar = (long)(*(++aString)) ) > 0x00 )
 *(aTable+aChar) = kEndOfAlphaList;
     * Build precursor linked index list
     *     This list is only used to produce the 
     *     AlphaList below. The precursor and
     *     the AlphaList are rebuilt for each
     *     new fragment that will be searched for.
 precursor= storage->precursor;
 aString= fragment - 1;
 index  = 0;
 count  = 0;
 while( (aChar = (long)(*(++aString))) > 0x00 )
 index = *(aTable+aChar); // get prev head
 *(aTable+aChar) = count; // put new head
 *(precursor+count) = index;// store prev head
 storage->fragmentSize = count;
     * Build AlphaList
     *     by walking each alphabet character's precursor 
     *     list and writing the index list into the 
     *     AlphaList the algorithm gets a sorted list of
     *     indexes into the fragment for each letter in the
     *     alphabet. The aTable will point to the first entry
     *     in the AlphaList and the last entry of each 
     *     character list is equal to the constant 
     *     kEndOfAlphaList ( = -1 ). Note that AlphaList
     *     location 0 is used to ignore database characters
     *     which are not in the given alphabet (it was free).
 alphaList = precursor + count;
 *(alphaList) = kEndOfAlphaList;
 aString = alphabet - 1;
 count = 1;
 while( (aChar = (long)(*(++aString)) ) > 0x00 )
 index = *(aTable+aChar);
 *(aTable+aChar) = count;
 while( index != kEndOfAlphaList )
 *(alphaList+count) = index;
 index = *(precursor+index);
 *(alphaList+count) = kEndOfAlphaList;
 storage->alphaList= alphaList;
 storage->matchQueue = alphaList + count + 1;
}// end of BuildAlphaList

/********* ********* ********* ********* ********* ********
 * FindMatch
 * For each character in the database increment every
 * match count that has the same character ( a hit ).
 * If after all possible alignments have been tallied,
 * the match count is greater than or equal to the value
 * of the threshold, then a match has been found.
 * Add the matching entry to the return array and continue
 * until all database characters have been tested.
 ********* ********* ********* ********* ********* ********/

long FindMatch(  // return number of matches
 char *alphabet, // legal characters in database
 char *database, // the reference database
 void *storage,  // pre-allocated storage
 char *fragment, // the fragment to find
 long diffsAllowed,// num of diffs allowed between
    //  a "match" and the fragment
 long matchPosition[]// match return array
 DNAStore *theStore; // typed storage
 short  *matchTop; // top of match array
 short  *matchCur; // current match array entry
 short  *aTable; // alpha to aList index table
 short  *aList;  // array of hit offsets
 short  *hitOffset;// current hit offset entry
 char   *dbString; // current database char entry
 long   dbChar;  // current database character
 long   count;   // current database location
 long   numMatch;// number of matches found
 long   fragSize;// fragment size in bytes
 long   loop;    // loop counter
 long   hitPos;  // current hit offset position
 long   threshold; // the threshold for matching
 theStore = (DNAStore*)storage;
 BuildAlphaList( alphabet,fragment,theStore);
 fragSize = theStore->fragmentSize;
 matchTop = theStore->matchQueue;
 matchCur = matchTop + fragSize;
 = (long)(matchCur+fragSize)-(long)theStore;
     * Clear the Match Count Array
     *     clear out the match counts for the entire array
 for( count=0; count<fragSize; count++ )
 *(matchCur+fragSize) = 0;
 *matchCur- = 0;

     * Walk the Database
     *    The match count array is a double size circular
     *    queue of match counts. It is double size so I do
     *    not need to check the array bounds in the inner
     *    match count increment loop.
 dbString = database - 1;
 aTable = theStore->alphaTable;
 aList = theStore->alphaList;
 threshold = fragSize-diffsAllowed;

 numMatch = 0;
 count = -fragSize;// count = current database loc.
 while( (dbChar = (long)(*(++dbString))) > 0x00 )
    // circular queue reset to center
 if( matchCur == matchTop )
 matchCur += fragSize;
    // check for a match to the fragment
 if((*matchCur+*(matchCur+fragSize)) >= threshold )
 matchPosition[ numMatch ] = count;
    // clear both old counts
 *matchCur = 0;
 *(matchCur+fragSize) = 0;

    // increment match counts for all possible
    //     fragment alignments
 hitOffset = aList + *(aTable + dbChar) - 1;
 while( (hitPos = (long)(*(++hitOffset))) >= 0 )
 *(matchCur + hitPos ) += 1;
    // The match count queue is walked in reverse
    //     order through memory because the alphaList
    //     indexes are positive.
     * Check the remaining match count entries for
     *    any fragments that extend beyond the end of
     *    the database.
 for( loop=0; loop < diffsAllowed; loop++)
 if( matchCur == matchTop )
 matchCur += fragSize;
 if((*matchCur+*(matchCur+fragSize)) >= threshold )
 matchPosition[ numMatch ] = count;
    // end of DNA_Match.c


Community Search:
MacTech Search:

Software Updates via MacUpdate

Notion 2.1.9 - A unified workspace for m...
Notion is the unified workspace for modern teams. Features: Integration with Slack Documents Wikis Tasks More guests: invite up to 10 collaborators, friends & family to your pages Page... Read more
Spotify - Stream music, creat...
Spotify is a streaming music service that gives you on-demand access to millions of songs. Whether you like driving rock, silky R&B, or grandiose classical music, Spotify's massive catalogue puts... Read more
Thunderbird 102.5.1 - Email client from...
As of July 2012, Thunderbird has transitioned to a new governance model, with new features being developed by the broader free software and open source community, and security fixes and improvements... Read more
Pinegrow 7.03 - Mockup and design web pa...
Pinegrow (was Pinegrow Web Designer) is desktop app that lets you mockup and design webpages faster with multi-page editing, CSS and LESS styling, and smart components for Bootstrap, Foundation,... Read more
Adobe After Effects 2022 23.1 - Create p...
The new, more connected Adobe After Effects can make the impossible possible. Get powerful new features like a Live 3D Pipeline that brings CINEMA 4D scenes in as layers - without intermediate... Read more
SteerMouse 5.6.7 - Powerful third-party...
SteerMouse is an advanced driver for USB and Bluetooth mice. SteerMouse can assign various functions to buttons that Apple's software does not allow, including double-clicks, modifier clicks,... Read more
Wireshark 4.0.2 - Network protocol analy...
Wireshark is one of the world's foremost network protocol analyzers, and is the standard in many parts of the industry. It is the continuation of a project that started in 1998. Hundreds of... Read more
Adobe Premiere Pro 2022 23.1 - Digital v...
Adobe Premiere Pro is available as part of Adobe Creative Cloud for as little as $54.99/month. The price on display is a price for annual by-monthly plan for Adobe Premiere Pro only. Adobe Premiere... Read more
1Password 8.9.10 - Powerful password man...
1Password is a password manager that uniquely brings you both security and convenience. It is the only program that provides anti-phishing protection and goes beyond password management by adding Web... Read more
FotoMagico 6.3 - Powerful slideshow crea...
FotoMagico lets you create professional slideshows from your photos and music with just a few, simple mouse clicks. It sports a very clean and intuitive yet powerful user interface. High image... Read more

Latest Forum Discussions

See All

SwitchArcade Round-Up: ‘Chained Echoes’,...
Hello gentle readers, and welcome to the SwitchArcade Round-Up for December 8th, 2022. Today is Thursday, and that usually means an absolute deluge of new releases on the eShop. But the year is winding down, so we’ve only got ten or so to look at... | Read more »
‘Awaken Legends: Idle RPG’ Celebrates th...
Awaken Legends: Idle RPG is adding its first update since the game was soft-launched in November, letting players get their hands on a new hero “Hera Valen". Players can also look forward to the Covenant of the Dark Knight event and the Wishing Well... | Read more »
‘Horizon Chase 2’ Japan World Tour Expan...
Horizon Chase 2 () from Aquiris is getting a major expansion today on Apple Arcade. The Japan World Tour expansion brings in 11 new races across 9 cities and it should be rolling out now as of this writing. I expect it to be available worldwide... | Read more »
Dark Fantasy Visual Novel ‘The 13th Mont...
Originally announced for release in August, The 13th Month from Japanese developer Kobayashimaru and publisher Kodansha released on PC via Steam worldwide this month. The dark fantasy visual novel that reimagines the classic Sleeping Beauty tale, is... | Read more »
Tom Clancey’s The Divison Resurgence ann...
Ubisoft has announced the latest Live Test dates for Tom Clancy’s The Division Resurgence, the hotly anticipated mobile entry in the Divison series. Starting December 8th and ending on the 22nd, the test will offer a huge amount of content for the... | Read more »
‘Easy Come Easy Golf’ New Update Adds St...
Easy Come Easy Golf () from Clap Hanz is one of my favorite games on Apple Arcade. It has been updated quite a bit since launch bringing in new modes and improvements. It recently launched on Nintendo Switch as well. | Read more »
Out Now: ‘Magic vs Metal’, ‘Suzerain’, ‘...
Each and every day new mobile games are hitting the App Store, and so each week we put together a big old list of all the best new releases of the past seven days. Back in the day the App Store would showcase the same games for a week, and then... | Read more »
SwitchArcade Round-Up: Reviews Featuring...
Hello gentle readers, and welcome to the SwitchArcade Round-Up for December 7th, 2022. Today can be accurately described as Mikhail Madness, with a whopping four reviews from our pal-est of pals. Football Manager 2023 Touch, Wobbledogs, Soccer Story... | Read more »
Alchemy Stars celebrates 1 and a half ye...
It has been one and a half years since Alchemy Stars launched, and Level Infinite is celebrating in style with a host of new content. There will be a new story mission and even a store to explore, and a whole new mode for those budding idol... | Read more »
Fighting Game ‘Art of Fighting 2’ ACA Ne...
Last week, side-scrolling shooter Pulstar hit mobile platforms as the newest ACA NeoGeo series release from Hamster and SNK. Read Shaun’s review of it here. Today, fighting game Art of Fighting 2 has launched on iOS and Android. Art of Fighting 2... | Read more »

Price Scanner via

New! Details on Verizon’s Christmas/Holiday p...
Verizon is offering discounts on iPhones, Apple Watch models, and iPads with specific promo codes as part of their Christmas/Holiday 2022 offerings. Codes are valid when adding a new line of service... Read more
Apple MagSafe accessories are back on Holiday...
Amazon has Apple MagSafe Chargers and Apple’s MagSafe Battery on sale for up to 24% off MSRP again as part of their Christmas/Holiday sale. Shipping is free, and all models are in stock: – MagSafe... Read more
13″ M2 MacBook Airs on sale again for the low...
Amazon has 13″ MacBook Airs with M2 CPUs in stock today and on sale for $150 off MSRP as part of their Christmas/Holiday Sale, prices start at $1049. Shipping is free. They are the lowest prices... Read more
Get an Apple 16″ MacBook Pro for $400 off MSR...
16″ MacBook Pros with Apple’s M1 Pro CPUs are in stock and on sale today at B&H Photo for $300-$400 off Apple’s MSRP for a limited time. Prices start at $2099 for M1 Pro models with 512GB or 1TB... Read more
Holiday clearance sale! Previous-generation A...
Amazon has 2nd generation 32GB and 64GB 4K Apple TVs with Siri remotes and 32GB Apple TV HDs on clearance sale for $80-$90 off original MSRP. Shipping is free, and delivery is available in time for... Read more
Christmas sale at Verizon: Apple AirPods Pro...
Verizon has first-generation Apple AirPods Pro on sale for $159.99 on their online store as part of their continuing Christmas/Holiday sale. Their price is $90 off Apple’s original MSRP, and it’s the... Read more
New Christmas/New Years promo at Xfinity Mobi...
Switch to Xfinity Mobile and open a new line of service, and take $400 off the price of a new iPhone, no trade-in required, through January 10, 2023. The $400 is applied to your account as credits... Read more
Apple iPad Smart Keyboard Folio prices drop u...
Apple iPad Smart Keyboard Folio prices have dropped up to $60 off MSRP at Amazon and Walmart as part of their Christmas/Holiday sales. These are the cheapest prices currently available for these iPad... Read more
Today is the final day for Xfinity Mobile’s $...
If you switch to Xfinity Mobile and open a new line of service, they will take $500 off the price of a new iPhone, no trade-in required. This is the best no trade-in Cyber Monday Apple iPhone 14 deal... Read more
Amazon restocks 10.2″ 64GB 9th-generation iPa...
Amazon has Apple’s 9th generation 10.2″ 64GB WiFi iPads (Silver) in stock and on sale for $269.99 shipped as part of their Christmas/Holiday Sale. Their price is $60 off Apple’s MSRP. Free delivery... Read more

Jobs Board

*Apple* Systems Administrator - JAMF - Activ...
…Administration **Duties and Responsibilities** + Configure and maintain the client's Apple Device Management (ADM) solution. The current solution is JAMF supporting Read more
Cashier - *Apple* Blossom Mall - JCPenney (...
Cashier - Apple Blossom Mall Location:Winchester, VA, United States ( - Apple Blossom Mall Read more
Omnichannel Associate - *Apple* Blossom Mal...
Omnichannel Associate - Apple Blossom Mall Location:Winchester, VA, United States ( - Apple Read more
Sephora Beauty Advisor - *Apple* Blossom Ma...
Sephora Beauty Advisor - Apple Blossom Mall Location:Winchester, VA, United States ( - Apple Read more
Operations Associate - *Apple* Blossom Mall...
Operations Associate - Apple Blossom Mall Location:Winchester, VA, United States ( - Apple Read more
All contents are Copyright 1984-2011 by Xplain Corporation. All rights reserved. Theme designed by Icreon.