TweetFollow Us on Twitter

Sep 90 Letters
Volume Number:6
Issue Number:9
Column Tag:Letters

A Call For Benchmarks

By Kirk Chase, Editor, MacTutor

Mouser Info Needed

David Landowne

Miami, FL

Help! I’ve been reading MacTutor for four years, great mag, but today I’m trying to track down a hot tip from the April 90 issue. In your Letter column, Greg Poole talks about the Mouser 1.2d5 and says it is available on AppleLink in the MacApp discussion folder. Soo I go to my local Link and in 20 minutes cannot find a MacApp folder or Mouser or anything with 1.2d5 in the software library. My host gets bored and says he’ll try later.

Do you have any further info or can you contact Greg Poole for me and find this browsing tool. It sounds like just what I need at my point in the learning curve.

While I have the line open, an answer to Mike Scanlin is

andi #0x8007
bpl  @1
ori  #0xFFF8
@1

Thanks and thanks for having such a great MacTutor.

[Mouser is now included in MacApp 2.0 which is available from APDA and on AppleLink, Developer Services:Macintosh Development Tool Discussions: MacApp Discussion:Mouser.-ed]

Benchmark Challenge

Walt Davis, Steve Bayer

Webster, TX

If you ask experienced programmers which language, C or Pascal, produces a faster implementation of a given algorithm on a given machine, we’d bet at least 9 out of 10 would choose C. Experienced programmers know C is closer to the native machine language, provides register variables, and is more flexible than Pascal. After all, wasn’t Unix written in C? Besides, Pascal is perceived as a higher-level language than C used mostly for teaching. Aren’t higher-level languages generally slower?

Imagine our surprise when we ran some simple comparison tests using Symantec’s THINK C 4.0 and THINK Pascal 2.0 compilers for the Mac. It all started over a discussion about the comparative performance of Case (Switch in C) and the If-Then_Else language constructs. Since we expected Case (or Switch) to be a specialized form of the If-Then-Else, we expected Case to be quicker and for the most part our results showed this to be true for both C and Pascal compilers. The code we used for our tests is summarized below:

{1}

Pascal

{If-Then-Else Test Procedure }
procedure TestIfThenElse;
var
 i, startT, stopT: longint;
 b: integer;
begin
 GetDateTime(startT);
 for i:= 1 to 1000000 do
 begin
 if b = 1 then
 begin
 end
 else if b = 2 then
 begin
 end
  
 else if b = 15 then
 begin
 end;
 end;
 GetDateTime(stopT);
 ShowElapsedTime(startT, stopT);
end;

{ Case Test Procedure }
procedure TestCase;
var
 b: integer;
 i, startT, stopT: longint;
begin
 GetDateTime(startT);
 for i := 1 to 1000000 do
 begin
 case b of
 1:
 begin
 end;
 2:
 begin
 end;
  
 15:
 begin
 end;
 otherwise
 end;
 end;
 GetDateTime(stopT);
 ShowElapsedTime(startT, stopT);
end;

/* 2 */

C

/* If-Then-Else Test Function */
TestIfThenElse() {
int b;
long i, startT, stopT;

GetDateTime(&startT)
for (i = 0; i < 1000000; i++) {
 if (b==1) {} else
 if (b==2) {} else
  
 if (b==15) {};
}
GetDateTime(&stopT);
ShowElapsedTime(startT, stopT);
}

/* Switch Test Procedure */
TestSwitch() {
int b;
long i, startT, stopT;

GetDateTime(&startT);
for (i = 0; i < 1000000; i++) {
 switch (b) {
 case (1):
 break;
 case (2):
 break;
  
 case (15):
 break;
 }
}
GetDateTime(&stopT);
ShowElapsedTime(startT, stopT);
}

The If-Then and Case/Switch constructs in the test procedures and functions compare the variable b with integer values from 1 through 15. We measured the time it took to complete one million loops for values of b ranging from 1 to 20. There were no Mac Toolbox calls within the loops so no conversion from C to Pascal was required, and we compiled all code with the math coprocessor option disabled. We ran identical tests on the Mac Plus, Mac SE, and Mac II models under Finder, not MultiFinder. Table 1 shows our results in tabular form and Figure 1 shows a chart of the results for the Mac Plus Tests.

Table 1. Time (seconds) To Execute If-Then-Else versus Case/Switch Procedures

Figure 1. Test Results For If-Then-Else versus Switch/Case on a Mac Plus

Our tests show a similar relationship between the If-Then-Else and Case constructs in Pascal and the If-Then-Else and Switch constructs in C. The surprising results of our tests is that, depending on the machine, it can take anywhere from 60% to over 100% longer to execute a particular language construct in C than it does in Pascal. These results really just point out the obvious; that the relative speed of a high-level language depends on the assembly language produced by the compiler and not the high-level language itself.

In closing, we would like to challenge MacTutor and its readers to repeat these tests using the Symantec compilers on similar hardware platforms to verify our results. Do these results hold for other compilers, e.g. MPW? How do other languages like Fortran and Modula-2 compare? Do these results hold for other language constructs besides the ones tested here?

SANE Bypass Help Needed

Martin E. Huber

Boulder, CO

I am a scientific/technical researcher and use the Macintosh for lengthy numerical simulations of physical systems. I would like to get every bit of speed I can out of the floating-point co-processor (FPU) and am not sure my current compiler uses it to its full potential. The accuracy provided by the 68881/68882 chips is more than sufficient for my needs the SANE standards are over-kill.

I have heard somewhere (I don’t remember where) that there are a few different ways programs on the Mac execute floating point operations. First, the FPU can be ignored altogether, in which case SANE uses the CPU for all operations. Second, if a FPU is present, SANE routines are used, but the routines use the FPU. Finally, the floating point operations can bypass SANE altogether and be passed directly to the FPU. Is this description accurate?

If so, I would like to find a compiler which bypasses SANE for ALL arithmetic functions (including add/subtract, multiply/divide), not just for the transcendental functions. Does such a beast exist? (I’ve heard that some compilers which make “direct” FPU calls still end up running through SANE.) Can you tell me which compiler provides the fastest running number-crunching code on a Mac with a FPU (in each of the languages Fortran, Pascal, Basic, and C, if possible), or at least where I might find such information? I haven’t seen any compilation of benchmark results lately. Thanks for any assistance you can provide.

Metrowerks Modula-2

Greg Galanos

Metrowerks, Inc.

The Trimex Bldg, Rte 11

Mooers, NY, 12958.

I would like to respond to Allen Stenger’s letter, which appeared in the July issue of MacTutor, by clarifying a certain number of technical points brought up with respect to the Metrowerks Modula-2 Professional Standalone Edition compiler. Before starting I would like to thank Allen for his perceptive comments.

The peculiar-looking code that Allen refers to, implemented through a jump table, is uniquely the runtime support necessary to implement functions not supported by the 68000 processor. All normal procedures are called in the usual method used on the Motorola processor family. (I will come back to this issue during the discussion on dynamic linking). Metrowerks Modula-2 PSE generates native 68000 (or 68020/030) code, the above being one of only two instances where jump tables are used. The second instance is in the treatment of CASE statements and this is due to change in a subsequent releases this year.

Allen is correct in stating that the debugger does not like anchored variables. The main reason is that when we upgraded the PSE compiler to correctly handle AVs to provide source-code compatibility with the MPW compiler, we forgot to upgrade the debugger to handle their display. However this will be fixed in the next release, due around the same time as this issue will appear.

A point of clarification on the rumored TML Modula-2 compiler, which was written by Bob Campbell and licensed to TML Systems for publishing. Unfortunately for reasons unknown, but certainly not because of the quality of the Campbell compiler, TML decided to withdraw the compiler from the marketplace and thus lost the distribution rights to the product.

Metrowerks decided that the Campbell compiler was an extremely well written MPW compiler and entered into a joint development and publishing agreement with Mr. Campbell last November. Since then, and until market introduction in April 1990, the developers have been working on bringing both the PSE and MPW compilers up to source-code compatibility (while the anchored variable display in the debugger went unnoticed).

On compiler speed, Allen mentioned that the PSE compiler is half as fast as the Sempersoft compiler. We have not been able to find the mentioned compiler on the market but this is an unfair comparison. The PSE compiler may take more time during the symbol file importation but this is due to the fact that we are giving the user a graphical progress report of the compilation pass and this certainly slows down imports because of the screen updating. This is not the case for an MPW tool.

We did however check compile times between the Modula-2 MPW Edition, MPW Pascal and MPW C and the following table displays the hand-checked results of compiling the TubeTest example program distributed with MPW by MacDTS.

MPW Edition MPW Pascal MPW C

6 6 11

(in seconds on a Mac-IIci, MPW 3.1, compiler versions 3.1)

These results lead us to believe that the Metrowerks compilers hold their own on compile speed when comparing apples with apples (no pun intended).

Dynamic Linking Explained

Now for the lengthiest part of this letter, clarifying bulky code. If anyone would care to examine an .obm file containing the object code produced by the PSE compiler, I’m sure they will notice that the code produced is short and sweet. The method used to produce a fast prototyping system in our case is called dynamic link-loading. This does not reduce compile time, but radically cuts link time through the use of dynamic links.

We use a program stack while your program is executing within the Metrowerks environment. The object files generated by the compiler are completely relocatable and need not be patched. They are merely ready to be loaded. Besides the main module, which is called to be executed at the highest level of the program stack, all modules that are directly or indirectly imported by the main program are loaded and linked with one important exception which is in the case of memory-resident modules.

A large percentage of the imported modules are already part of the resident Metrowerks shell. For instance FileIO and QuickDraw or any number of toolbox and OS managers are being used by the shell to implement the multi-window text editor, or the compiler parser/scanner. In the case where one of these modules is directly or indirectly imported by the main program the linker/loader sets up a dynamic link to the memory-resident module instead of reloading it from disk.

This permits high speed dynamic linking which provides fast compile, debug and execute cycles within the environment. When the main program completes execution, it is removed from memory along with the other imported modules that are not memory-resident. The actual implementation of the program stack is simply the following:

PROCEDURE Call (module: ARRAY OF CHAR;
           leaveLoaded: BOOLEAN; VAR   status: Status);

PROCEDURE ExecuteObmFile(name: ARRAY OF CHAR;
                         enterDebug: BOOLEAN);
VAR
  status :    Status;
BEGIN
...
  Call(name, FALSE, status);
 ...
END ExecuteObmFile;

The advantage of dynamic linking is fast turnaround time as well as the fact that your own finished application can also implement this scheme. The System.Call mechanism can be used by any program compiled with the PSE compiler. The advantage of a program stack call is that the stack is not limited to 32k segments. It may be as large as the memory available as long as the data and code size of an individual module either imported or importing is not larger than 32k each.

The tradeoff on dynamic linking is that because the nature of the link is dynamic we cannot, at this time, remove unused code (sometimes referred to as dead code) from the linked application without removing the System.Call facility. It is precisely this tradeoff that makes the produced application, and not the generated object code, larger than for instance an MPW produced application. We are currently investigating whether we will write an incremental linker or wait until Apple comes up with one.

However, this does not mean that Metrowerks Modula-2 PSE is not suitable for applications development, the proof of the pudding being that the entire Metrowerks Modula-2 Professional Standalone Edition bootstraps itself and is linked by PSE under the above mentioned dynamic linking scheme.

For those of you who do want the fast-prototyping capabilities of PSE but also want the linking capabilities of MPW, we suggest prototyping on PSE and delivering the final product on the Metrowerks MPW Edition compiler. These can be purchased separately or as a bundle for less than $300. Source-code compatibility between the two compilers gives anyone a reasonably priced solution to having the best of both worlds.

 

Community Search:
MacTech Search:

Software Updates via MacUpdate

LibreOffice 6.4.5.2 - Free, open-source...
LibreOffice is an office suite (word processor, spreadsheet, presentations, drawing tool) compatible with other major office suites. The Document Foundation is coordinating development and... Read more
Thunderbird 68.10.0 - Email client from...
As of July 2012, Thunderbird has transitioned to a new governance model, with new features being developed by the broader free software and open source community, and security fixes and improvements... Read more
Firefox 78.0.1 - Fast, safe Web browser.
Firefox offers a fast, safe Web browsing experience. Browse quickly, securely, and effortlessly. With its industry-leading features, Firefox is the choice of Web development professionals and casual... Read more
BetterTouchTool 3.389 - Customize multi-...
BetterTouchTool adds many new, fully customizable gestures to the Magic Mouse, Multi-Touch MacBook trackpad, and Magic Trackpad. These gestures are customizable: Magic Mouse: Pinch in / out (zoom)... Read more
Slack 4.7.0 - Collaborative communicatio...
Slack brings team communication and collaboration into one place so you can get more work done, whether you belong to a large enterprise or a small business. Check off your to-do list and move your... Read more
OsiriX Lite 11.0.3 - 3D medical image pr...
OsiriX Lite is an image processing software dedicated to DICOM images (".dcm" / ".DCM" extension) produced by medical equipment (MRI, CT, PET, PET-CT, ...) and confocal microscopy (LSM and BioRAD-PIC... Read more
Wireshark 3.2.5 - Network protocol analy...
Wireshark is one of the world's foremost network protocol analyzers, and is the standard in many parts of the industry. It is the continuation of a project that started in 1998. Hundreds of... Read more
Dabble 1.6.1 - Organize your manuscript,...
Dabble organizes your manuscript, story notes, and plot. Dabble simplifies the story, leaving more room in your brain to create, which is what being a writer is really about. Organize your story.... Read more
Quicken 5.17.0 - Complete personal finan...
Quicken makes managing your money easier than ever. Whether paying bills, upgrading from Windows, enjoying more reliable downloads, or getting expert product help, Quicken's new and improved features... Read more
Tor Browser 9.5.1 - Anonymize Web browsi...
The Tor Browser Bundle is an easy-to-use portable package of Tor, Vidalia, Torbutton, and a Firefox fork preconfigured to work together out of the box. It contains a modified copy of Firefox that... Read more

Latest Forum Discussions

See All

Detective Di is a point-and-click murder...
Detective Di is a point-and-click murder mystery set in Tang Dynasty-era China. You'll take on the role of China's best-known investigator, Di Renjie, as he solves a series of grisly murders that will ultimately lead him on a collision course with... | Read more »
Dissidia Final Fantasy Opera Omnia is se...
Dissidia Final Fantasy Opera Omnia, one of Square Enix's many popular mobile RPGs, has announced a plethora of in-game events that are set to take place over the summer. This will include several rewards, Free Multi Draws and more. [Read more] | Read more »
Sphaze is a neat-looking puzzler where y...
Sphaze is a neat-looking puzzler where you'll work to guide robots through increasingly elaborate mazes. It's set in a visually distinct world that's equal parts fantasy and sci-fi, and it's finally launched today for iOS and Android devices. [... | Read more »
Apple Arcade is in trouble
Yesterday, Bloomberg reported that Apple is disappointed in the performance of Apple Arcade and will be shifting their approach to the service by focusing on games that can retain subscribers and canceling other upcoming releases that don't fit... | Read more »
Pixel Petz, an inventive platform for de...
Pixel Petz has built up a sizeable player base thanks to its layered, easy-to-understand creative tools and friendly social experience. It revolves around designing, trading, and playing with a unique collection of pixel art pets, and it's out now... | Read more »
The King of Fighters Allstar's late...
The King of Fighters ALLSTAR, Netmarble's popular action RPG, has once again been updated with a plethora of new content. This includes battle cards, events and 21 new fighters, which increases the already sizeable roster even more. [Read more] | Read more »
Romancing SaGa Re;univerSe, the mobile s...
Square Enix latest mobile spin-off Romancing SaGa Re;univerSe is available now globally for both iOS and Android. It initially launched in Japan back in 2018 where it's proven to be incredibly popular, so now folks in the West can finally see what... | Read more »
Away: Journey to the Unexpected is a sto...
Away: Journey to the Unexpected looks really quite lovely. Stylish, cute, and clearly heavily inspired by Japanese animation, it's amongst the best-looking mobile games on the horizon. Developed by a two-person team, this story-driven rogue-lite... | Read more »
Black Desert Mobile is giving away free...
Pearl Abyss has just announced that it will continue to offer special in-game rewards to Black Desert Mobile players who also happen to be Amazon Prime subscribers. The rewards will be sent out over the next three months, and today's news comes... | Read more »
Golf on Mars "review"
| Read more »

Price Scanner via MacPrices.net

July 4th Sale: $100 off every 2020 13″ MacBoo...
Apple resellers have new 2020 13″ MacBook Airs on sale for $100 off Apple’s MSRP as part of their July 4th sales. Starting at $899, these are the cheapest new 2020 MacBooks for sale anywhere: (1) B... Read more
This hidden deal on Apple’s site can save you...
Are you a local, state, or federal government employee? If so, Apple offers special government pricing on their products, including AirPods, for you as well as immediate family members. Here’s how... Read more
Apple Watch Series 3 models on sale for new l...
Amazon has Apple Watch Series 3 GPS models on sale for $30 off MSRP, starting at only $169. Their prices are the lowest available for these models from any Apple reseller. Choose Amazon as the seller... Read more
Deal Alert! Get these refurbished 2018 13″ Ma...
Apple has restocked and lowered prices on select Certified Refurbished 2018 13″ MacBook Airs, starting at only $679. Each MacBook features a new outer case, comes with a standard Apple one-year... Read more
July 4th Sale: 13″ 2.0GHz MacBook Pros for $2...
B&H Photo has new 2020 13″ 2.0GHz MacBook Pros on sale for $200 off Apple’s MSRP as part of their July 4th sale. Prices start at $1599. These are the same MacBook Pros sold by Apple in their... Read more
July 1 only: $100 off Apple iPhone 11, 11 Pro...
Boost Mobile is offering Apple iPhone 11, 11 Pro, and iPhone 11 Pro Max models for $100 off MSRP with service. Their discount reduces the cost of an iPhone 11/64GB to $599, iPhone 11 Pro to $899 for... Read more
Apple offers $50-$100 Education discount on i...
Purchase a new 12.9″ or 11″ iPad Pro at Apple using your Education discount, and Apple will take $50-$100 off their MSRP. All teachers, students, and staff of any educational institution with a .edu... Read more
Apple has Series 5 Apple Watch models availab...
Apple has Certified Refurbished Apple Watch Series 5 WiFi models available for $60 off MSRP, starting at $339. Each Watch includes Apple’s standard one-year warranty and free shipping: – 44mm Apple... Read more
Use our exclusive price trackers at MacPrices...
Looking for a new 2020 13″ MacBook Air or one of the new 2020 iPad Pros? Our Apple award-winning price trackers are the best place to look for the lowest prices and latest sales on Apple gear. Scan... Read more
Clearance Mac minis available for only $679,...
Apple reseller DataVision has clearance, previous-generation Mac minis available for up to $120 off Apple’s original MSRP, each including free shipping. Prices start at $679. DataVision charges... Read more

Jobs Board

Perioperative RN - ( *Apple* Hill Surgical C...
Perioperative RN - ( Apple Hill Surgical Center) Tracking Code 60593 Job Description Monday - Friday - Full Time Days Possible Saturdays General Summary: Under the Read more
Product Manager, *Apple* Commercial Sales -...
Product Manager, Apple Commercial Sales Austin, TX, US Requisition Number:77652 As an Apple Product Manager for the Commercial Sales team at Insight, you Read more
*Apple* Mac Product Engineer - Barclays (Uni...
Apple Mac EngineerWhippany, NJ Support the development and delivery of solutions, products, and capabilities into the Barclays environment working across technical Read more
Blue *Apple* Cafe Student Worker - Pennsylv...
…enhance your work experience. Student positions are available at the Blue Apple Cafe. Employee meal discount during working hours. Duties include food preparation, Read more
Blue *Apple* Cafe Student Worker - Fall - P...
…to enhance your work experience. Student positions are available at the Blue Apple Cafe. Employee meal discount during working hours is provided. Duties include food Read more
All contents are Copyright 1984-2011 by Xplain Corporation. All rights reserved. Theme designed by Icreon.