TweetFollow Us on Twitter

Code Re-construction
Volume Number:2
Issue Number:9
Column Tag:Nosy News

The Art of Code Re-construction

By Steve Jasik, Menlo Park, CA

In this special article by the famous industry guru Steve Jasek, author of MacNosy, we get the inside scoop on the inner workings of Nosy and how to use it to best advantage. Since Steve is famous for his brief documentation, these pearls of wisdom will be most valuable, but be warned; this is not for the faint hearted, as Steve's technical background in compiler design is clearly evident. -Ed.

Sniffing Around with MacNosy

As I sit here pecking away on my Mac, it is mid June. Nosy 2.099 has been finalized and 2.1 is in progress. Most of the features I discuss in this article are in 2.099, and the rest will appear in 2.1 which will ship in July.

For starters, I'd like to try and answer some rhetorical questions such as:

What is and why use Nosy, and what advantage does it offer over other methods of obtaining information about programs?

Hypertext for programmmers

Nosy is a fancy disassembler with extensive reference map (Hypertext for programmmers?) and symbol substitution facilities that verges on being a de-compiler. Nosy can be used to obtain information about any program or resource that consists of 68000 native code. It does not handle Pcode, Mcode, etc. It can be used to obtain accurate and informative listings of the ROM (64 or 128K), resources on the system file, etc. It knows about the special structure of DRVR's (desk accessories) and PDEF's. It can create '.asm' files that can be fed into the MDS assembler. Later on this year it will be modified so that its output will be compatable with the MPW (Macintosh Programmer's Workshop) assembler.

Because it subdivides the program up into procedures and data blocks, and creates reference maps for those symbols, one is able to analyze what the program is doing without having to execute it in many cases. When Nosy is used in conjunction with a ".map" file produced by a Linker or the debug symbols left in the code by most compilers one can use it as a "source" level cross reference map facility for one's own program. This can aid in tracking down bugs or making modifications to the program. [Note: TML, LightSpeed and Consulair support debug code in their compilation that aids Nosy. -Ed.]

You Didn't Read this Section in MacTutor!

In the same vein one can use Nosy to locate and analyze copy protection code. Modifications scheduled for V2.1 will let one disassemble CODE segments from programs that are running in another partition under Switcher. This will allow one to analyze copy protection code that has been encrypted in the disk file copy of the program. The fun thing about this mod is that no program that is Switcher friendly will be able to protect against this form of copy protection analysis as they have no real way of knowing that Nosy is looking at them, and one will not need to make a debugger initially active, so programs that check for the presence of one, and then blowup will be hoodwinked. Note that some programs check for the presence of a debugger by inspecting the interrupt vector address's ( 0 to $100) to ensure that they reference ROM and blowup if they don't.

Fig. 1 Call Graph

Given the proper order of things in starting up Switcher, Nosy and the program to be analyzed, Nosy will temporarly put any debugger to "sleep" so any other program cannot detect its presence. After one has patched the code in the program that disables the debugger, one can wake up the debugger, and use a combination of it and Nosy to locate and disable the copy protection code. I am temped to offer a prize to anyone who can devise a method that cannot be cracked by Nosy. [Ouch! -Ed.]

More Coming

While I am in the process of teaching Nosy how to locate the CODE segments of running programs, I thought it would also be nice if Nosy was fixed so that it could disassemble arbitrarly large programs in 512K.

My motives for adding this facility at this time are two. Firstly to allow the analysis of programs that would not fit into memory, and secondly I will be needing more space for tables in order to do global data flow analysis soon.

You can also use Nosy for code inspection of your own application. As Nosy grows in size, I use Nosy on itself to look at the code generated by Lisa Pascal to see what code it is generating for a given sequence of statements, and when the code looks like it can be trimmed by choosing another sequence I rewrite it by using the type-casting facility, etc.

Other reasons for using Nosy are to learn about 68000 code, and how Macintosh applications are structured. The Nosy disk contains a number of interesting examples, including a fast Shell sort which is extensively commented, and describes my assembly language coding techniques.

Fig. 2 Flow Graph for above example

Compilers and Data Flow Analysis

Nosy makes use of a variety of techniques that are similar to those used in compilers. For example, it has a variety of symbol tables, which use the address of the symbol instead of the name as the primary lookup key. It also uses control and data flow analysis to obtain information about the structure of the program, but first some terminology and review. Control flow analysis, which concerns itself with the flow of execution in a program, is familiar to many programmmers.

A Basic block consists of a sequence of contigious statements such that if any statement in the block is executed, all are. Basic blocks end prior to an active label or after a jump instruction which would be representated in a higher level language by an if, case or goto statment. In a flow graph basic blocks are the nodes (the circles) and the edges are the possible flow paths of execution. (See fig. 1 for a diagram of a Basic Block). The usual conventions are that flow is from top to bottom with backward branchs representated as curved lines. The ground symbol represents the return statement. In the example below we have a simple for loop with a side branch that the programmmer would have written as:

 for j := Low to upLim do 
 if a[j] <> 0 then B[j] := B[j] / a[j];
 Return

In the process of analyzing the code, compilers will invent labels for basic blocks that are the target of branch instructions, which is why I rewrote the code in the diagram in fig. 2.

The process of collecting the flow of control information is a fairly simple one. Analyzing it to find the loops in the program, etc is slightly more complicated, but straightforward. When one does this on an inter-procedural level the resulting graph is called the "program call graph." Building a complete call graph in the presence of procedures that accept parameters as arguments is somewhat more difficult. For compilers this is no real problem, as very few of them do inter-procedural optimization. For Nosy it represents a real problem, as initially it does not know what the arguments to user procedures are or their types. To date, my solution to the problem has been to let the user supply the information manually by the Review data and IsProc commands which are discussed in the next section.

Fig. 3 Review Data command in window mode

Before we can discuss how Nosy can complete the call graph automatically, I need to say a bit about data flow analysis, which is the process of collecting information about the way variables are used in a program. In order to do effective global optimization or de-compilation one has to collect both control and data flow information. The exact sequence of events is that the control flow information for a procedure and the data flow tables for the basic blocks in a procedure are built first. Then the control flow information is used to "solve" the data flow equations globally. The questions that an optimizing compiler will be able to answer with the data flow information are:

What variables are not defined in the loop? The resulting set of expressions that use the variables are candidates for code motion out of the loop, etc.

When does the value of a variable that is assigned to a register in a loop have to be placed in memory prior to exit (is Live on exit) from a loop or more generally a basic block? This is usually called the Live/Dead information.

The information that a compiler collects for each variable/array in a basic block is called the use/def info, and consists of three bits for each variable; used in the block, defined in the block and used before definitation. From this and the control flow information one can develop the Live/Dead information.

For most real languages, the problem of building the use/def tables is compounded by alaising of names due to the presence of array references, or pointer variables which may point to the same location in memory at run-time. Most of you are familiar with the problem, but without giving it a name. As a simple example of alaising, consider the following sequence where p is a pointer to an integer:

p := addr(i);    { p is equivalenced or alaised to i }
x := A[i];
p^ := 2;
 y := A[i];    {would it be valid to change this to y := x;  ?? }

Given the above code it would be imprudent for an optimizing compiler to replace the second reference to A[i] ] with x, for example, since the value of i has been changed directly in memory, and thus the programmer expects x and y will have different values!

Fig. 4 IsProc command

The primary effect of alaising is to inhibit code optimization. Compilers for languages such as C, with its weak typing of pointer variables have a difficult time in producing good code in the presence of stores to pointer based variables.

Now back to Nosy. Another form of data flow problem concerns itself with determining the type of a variable based on its usage. This is the problem that Nosy has to solve if it is to automatically recognize procedural parameters and propagate this information back to the calls so that all code blocks will be recognized as such. To do this Nosy must perform a symbolic simulation of the 68000 registers and stack as it disassembles the instructions to determine the usage of variables in a basic block, and that it keep enough control flow information around so it can propagate the type information out of the procedure and back to the caller. I started to work on this problem a few weeks ago and got sidetracked by the needs of my documentator to complete window mode so that we could document the visable parts of Nosy. With luck I'll get back to it in time to show it off at the August MacWorld show.

As a final note in this section, the topics discussed here are relatively old hat, [! -Ed.] and one can find a more complete discussion of optimization and flow analysis in chapter 10 of the "Red Dragon" book by Aho, Sethi & Ullman (Addison-Wesley). It's correct title is "Compilers, Principles, techniques and Tools". It is a standard text book for Comp Sci undergraduates. I recommend its purchase to anyone who is interested in understanding the structure of compilers.

Fig. 5 Case Jumps

Using Nosy to reformat Data

Nosy analyzes a program by walking the tree of procedures to build the program call graph. At present, the treewalk is a one pass algorithm which recognizes the procedure entry points by their references in JSR's. Procedures that are passed as parameters (a common practice in Mac programs) are not recognized as code unless there is an explicit reference to them in a JSR. This creates the situation that not all the code is exposed by Nosy. To get around this problem, I created the Review data command which lets one inspect the data blocks, and reformat them as one wishs.

Now I have converted the Review data command to window mode, one can see the context in which a data block is referenced and do a more inteligent job of redefining the format of the block, be it code or otherwise.

When the Review data command is selected, Nosy cleans up the desktop by closing all the active windows except for the "-Notes-" window which is a scratchpad for your and Nosy's use. It then puts up a modeless dialog window for keyboard entry at the top of the screen, a menu window below it, a "-Data Blk-" window which displays the data block to be modified, and a '-Uses=" window with a display of a reference to the data block, if any exists. In Review data mode, all keyboard input is directed to the command window.

The illustration in figure 3 [RevDAT 1] shows the label data410 passed to APPENDST which we might guess to be a string concatenate routine. With this information, it is easy to surmise that data410 is a Pascal string. If one wanted to find out what APPENDST did, all one has to do is double click on the name and ctl-D to bring up a display of it. The only reason for reformatting all the data blocks in a program is if one wanted to "Cut and Paste" the code in it into another application.

An alternative way of reformatting data blocks in window mode is to mark them as procedure entry points with the "Is Proc" command. Data blocks marked as "IsProc" will be treated as the entry point to a procedure on all subsequent treewalks. In some programs, such as the PTCH resource in the System file, which contains the patchs to the ROM, it is easier to mark the data labels with the IsProc command then it is via Review data. Figure 4 [Ptch IsProc] illustrates the use of this command.

One hi-lites a data label, and then selects the "Is Proc" command. As an aside, note that most of the System Globals that begin with a lowercase j contain a pointer to the address of a routine, so one may Isproc them with impunity.

Case Statment Analysis

Another reason that all the code may not be apparant to Nosy is because of case statements that it cannot understand. The Case Jumps display (Fig. 5 next page) lets you determine which jumps are causing Nosy problems. The "Link Jump to Table" command lets you specify information about the jump so that Nosy can process it correctly the next time a treewalk is done. In figure 6 [Lnk JMP2] we see that the offending case jump table consists entirely of negative entries so Nosy has declined to set the length of the table at 7, which can be done with the dialog box in the upper left hand corner of the display. The basic problem is that during the treewalk when Nosy inspects the jump instruction, it does not know the length of the data block. Because all the jump table entries are negative, it is not sure where the table ends. When a jump table has at least one positive entry, Nosy can use that entry to determine the length of the jump table based on the assumption that code for the cases immediately follow the jump table.

The table format of this case statement is JUMPP, which means that the the jump table is to be interpreted as program relocatable offsets to procedure labels. The JUMPC format defines a case or switch table to be a set of jumps to com_ labels (code which is branched to by a JMP, BRA or Bxx instruction). The normal format for a case table which consists of jumps to labels local to a procedure is JUMPL. It is sometimes useful to break up a big procedure with a case table into smaller procedures by changing the format of the case table from JUMPL to JUMPC.

Closing thoughts

In writing the above section I was temped to go back, reinspect my algorithms and see if I couldn't automatically recognize the case discussed in the first example. After all, it is easier to solve the problem once in the product as opposed to have to explain it many times to others. Unfortunately Nosy does need human help in recognizing some patterns, and those of us who use it should be familiar with techniques for reformatting data, etc. Some time ago a famous industrial engineer, Peter Denning told an audience of Twist Drill manufacturers that what their customers wanted was not drills, but holes. I remind myself that what you want is information without hassle, and to that end I will continue to improve Nosy so the de-compilation process runs more on automatic, and less on manual. [Please help support Steve's efforts in our behalf by both BUYING Nosy and spreading the WORD, not the DISK. -Ed.]

Fig. 6 Correcting Table Jumps

 

Community Search:
MacTech Search:

Software Updates via MacUpdate

Iridient Developer 3.4.1 - Powerful imag...
Iridient Developer (was RAW Developer) is a powerful image-conversion application designed specifically for OS X. Iridient Developer gives advanced photographers total control over every aspect of... Read more
Vallum 3.3.4 - $15.00
Vallum is a little tool that helps you monitor and block apps connections and throttle apps bandwidth. It is able to intercept connections at the application layer, and hold them while you decide... Read more
DiskCatalogMaker 8.2.6 - Catalog your di...
DiskCatalogMaker is a simple disk management tool which catalogs disks. Simple, light-weight, and fast Finder-like intuitive look and feel Super-fast search algorithm Can compress catalog data for... Read more
SoftRAID 5.8.4 - High-quality RAID manag...
SoftRAID allows you to create and manage disk arrays to increase performance and reliability. SoftRAID allows the user to create and manage RAID 4 and 5 volumes, RAID 1+0, and RAID 1 (Mirror) and... Read more
Audio Hijack 3.7.3 - Record and enhance...
Audio Hijack (was Audio Hijack Pro) drastically changes the way you use audio on your computer, giving you the freedom to listen to audio when you want and how you want. Record and enhance any audio... Read more
CleanMyMac X 4.6.15 - Delete files that...
CleanMyMac makes space for the things you love. Sporting a range of ingenious new features, CleanMyMac lets you safely and intelligently scan and clean your entire system, delete large, unused files... Read more
Suitcase Fusion 21.2.1 - Font management...
Suitcase Fusion is the creative professional's font manager. Every professional font manager should deliver the basics: spectacular previews, powerful search tools, and efficient font organization.... Read more
Civilization VI 1.3.6 - Next iteration o...
Civilization® VI is the award-winning experience. Expand your empire across the map, advance your culture, and compete against history’s greatest leaders to build a civilization that will stand the... Read more
Dashlane 6.2042.0 - Password manager and...
Dashlane is an award-winning service that revolutionizes the online experience by replacing the drudgery of everyday transactional processes with convenient, automated simplicity - in other words,... Read more
Airfoil 5.9.2 - Send audio from any app...
Airfoil allows you to send any audio to AirPort Express units, Apple TVs, and even other Macs and PCs, all in sync! It's your audio - everywhere. With Airfoil you can take audio from any... Read more

Latest Forum Discussions

See All

Physics-based tower defense game Goblin...
Indie developer Arif Games has released Goblin Raiders on iOS and Android. [Read more] | Read more »
PUBG Mobile has provided yet another upd...
PUBG Mobile has been making a point of publicly mentioning all of their ongoing efforts to vanquish cheating from the popular battle royale. Today two teams within the company have provided updates on their progress. [Read more] | Read more »
Zombieland: AFK Survival is celebrating...
Zombieland: AFK Survival is currently celebrating its one-year anniversary. If you don't quite recognise the name that's because it initially launched as Zombieland: Double Tapper. Anyway, the game is celebrating turning one with two Halloween-... | Read more »
Distract Yourself With These Great Mobil...
There’s a lot going on right now, and I don’t really feel like trying to write some kind of pithy intro for it. All I’ll say is lots of people have been coming together and helping each other in small ways, and I’m choosing to focus on that as I... | Read more »
Genshin Impact Guide - Gacha Strategy: W...
If you're playing Genshin Impact without spending money, you'll always need to be looking for ways to optimize your play to maximize rewards without getting stuck in a position where you're tempted to spend. The most obvious trap here is the game'... | Read more »
Genshin Impact Adventurer's Guide
Hello and well met, fellow adventurers of Teyvat! Check out our all-in-one resource for all things Genshin Impact. We'll be sure to add more as we keep playing the game, so be sure to come back here to check for updates! [Read more] | Read more »
Genshin Impact Currency Guide - What...
Genshin Impact is great fun, but make no mistake: this is a gacha game. It is designed specifically to suck away time and money from you, and one of the ways the game does this is by offering a drip-feed of currencies you will feel compelled to... | Read more »
XCOM 2 Collection on iOS now available f...
The XCOM 2 Collection, which was recently announced to be coming to iOS in November, is now available to pre-order on the App Store. [Read more] | Read more »
Presidents Run has returned for the 2020...
IKIN's popular endless runner Presidents Run has returned to iOS and Android just in time for the 2020 election season. It will see players choosing their favourite candidate and guiding them on a literal run for presidency to gather as many votes... | Read more »
New update for Cookies Must Die adds new...
A new update for Rebel Twins’ platformer shooter Cookies Must Die is coming out this week. The update adds quite a bit to the game, including new levels and characters to play around with. [Read more] | Read more »

Price Scanner via MacPrices.net

Apple’s 16″ MacBook Pros are back in stock st...
Apple has Certified Refurbished 2019 16″ MacBook Pros back in stock for up to $420 off the cost of new models, starting at $2039. Each model features a new outer case, shipping is free, and an Apple... Read more
Use our exclusive iPhone Price Trackers to fi...
Looking for a new Apple iPhone 12 or 12 Pro? Perhaps a deal on last year’s iPhone 11? Check out our iPhone Price Tracker here at MacPrices.net. We track new and clearance iPhone prices from Apple as... Read more
Weekend deal: $100 off 13″ MacBook Airs at Am...
Amazon has new 2020 13″ MacBook Airs on sale for $100 off Apple’s MSRP, starting at only $899. Their prices are the lowest available for new MacBooks from any Apple resellers. These are the same 13″... Read more
New 10.9″ 64GB Apple iPad Air on sale for $55...
Amazon has Apple’s new 2020 10.9″ 64GB WiFi iPad Air on sale today for $549.99 shipped. That’s $40 off MSRP. Pre-orders are available today at this discounted price, and Amazon states that the iPad... Read more
Get a clearance 2019 27″ 5K iMac for up to $5...
Apple has Certified Refurbished 2019 27″ 5K iMacs available starting at $1439 and up to $520 off their original MSRP. Apple’s one-year warranty is standard and shipping is free. The following... Read more
AT&T offers the Apple iPhone 11 for $10/m...
AT&T is offering Apple’s 64GB iPhone 11 for $10 per month, for customers opening a new line of service, no trade-in required. Discount is applied via monthly bill credits over a 30 month period.... Read more
Apple’s 2020 11″ iPad Pros on sale today for...
Apple reseller Expercom has new 2020 11″ Apple iPad Pros on sale for $50-$75 off MSRP, with prices starting at $749. These are the same iPad Pros sold by Apple in their retail and online stores: – 11... Read more
Did Apple Drop The Ball By Not Branding Its C...
EDITORIAL: 10.21.20 – In the branding game, your marketing strategy can either be a hit or a miss and the latter is the case for Apple when it missed out on an opportunity to brand its “SE” series of... Read more
27″ 6-core and 8-core iMacs on sale for up to...
Adorama has Apple’s 2020 27″ 6-core and 8-core iMacs on sale today for $50-$100 off MSRP, with prices starting at $1749. Shipping is free: – 27″ 3.1GHz 6-core iMac: $1749, save $50 – 27″ 3.3GHz 6-... Read more
Apple’s 16″ MacBook Pros are on sale for $300...
B&H Photo has 16″ MacBook Pros on sale today for $300-$350 off Apple’s MSRP, starting at $2099. Expedited shipping is free to many addresses in the US. Their prices are among the lowest available... Read more

Jobs Board

*Apple* Mac, Windows & Mobile Device Sup...
Apple Mac, Windows & Mobile Device Support Engineer at created 30-Sep-2020"/> Skip to content **Xerox** at https://xerox.avature.net/en_US/careers Menu ** Apple Read more
Freelance Features Writer ( *Apple* Products...
…interested in iOS, watchOS, iPadOS, macOS? Do you like to explain and teach Apple products to other people with less understanding? If these things sound like you, Read more
Geek Squad *Apple* Consultation Professiona...
**788452BR** **Job Title:** Geek Squad Apple Consultation Professional **Job Category:** Store Associates **Store Number or Department:** 000401-Southland Read more
*Apple* Computing Specialist - Best Buy (Uni...
**789021BR** **Job Title:** Apple Computing Specialist **Job Category:** Store Associates **Store Number or Department:** 000109-West Los Angeles-Store **Job Read more
Chief Medical Officer, St. Mary Medical Cente...
…**Providence is calling a Chief Medical Officer to St. Mary Medical Center in Apple Valley, CA** **.** **THE ROLE** Under the direction of the Chief Executive, the Read more
All contents are Copyright 1984-2011 by Xplain Corporation. All rights reserved. Theme designed by Icreon.