TweetFollow Us on Twitter

December 94 - Balance of Power: PowerPC Branch Prediction

Balance of Power: PowerPC Branch Prediction

Dave Evans

The PowerPC processors try to predict which way your code will execute. This sounds surprisingly astrological for a digital machine, but it becomes very useful for a pipelined processor and will often speed up your code. In this column I'll go over why and how this works, focusing especially on the new PowerPC 604 processor prediction techniques, and I'll answer the question "Can a Power Macintosh really tell the future?"

PSYCHIC DECISIONS

Typically about one-seventh of the instructions in your code are branches, either to call subroutines or to make logical decisions in your program. The PowerPC processor would ordinarily tend to stall at branches, since it tries to work on more than one instruction at a time and it's not always sure which code it should execute after a branch. It could either take the branch or fall through, and often the processor won't know which until a couple of cycles later.

So the PowerPC processors allow for speculative execution, meaning they'll guess at the most probable direction the branch will go and then will issue those instructions. But the processor doesn't let the instructions commit until it's sure the guess was correct. Usually it guesses right, and a few instructions are already completed when the branch is decided. If the guess was wrong, it throws out those results and starts over with the correct code.

This predictive skill helps keep the processor executing successfully without stalls, and better prediction techniques will yield better overall performance. The new PowerPC 604 processor improves on earlier prediction techniques; I'll discuss all of them in detail below.

But first, a relevant astrological note: The "birthday" of the 601 makes it a Taurus, whereas then 603 is a Libra. The 604 chip had a birthday in April, so it's an Aries.

TAURUS AND LIBRA ARE COMPATIBLE

The PowerPC 601 and 603 processors use basically the same techniques to predict branches. For simple unconditional branches, for example, they both process and remove the branch early in the instruction issue stage. This operation, called branch folding, keeps the instruction stream moving without having to wait for the branch to be processed. The branch is handled early, and the new instructions are fetched from the cache immediately.

For conditional branches, both processors first try to handle the branch early in the instruction issue stage. If the condition being tested has already been evaluated, the branch is folded out of the instruction stream. But if the condition being tested is still in the pipeline, the processor must guess at the branch direction.

Prediction of guessed branches are based on two things: the direction of the branch and a software "hint" bit. If the direction is negative -- backward in your code -- the branch is taken (because loops often iterate a few times backward before falling through, and this heuristic is more often true). All other branches fall through by default. The hint bit is a way for the compiler to reverse this heuristic: if the bit is set, the prediction will be reversed.

As far as I know there are no compilers that allow you to specify the hint bit in your code, although this could be a valuable feature. Also, profilers or similar tools could take statistics on your code flow and then set the bits for you from trial runs of your software.

THE TEMPERAMENT OF ARIES

The PowerPC 604 has much better branch prediction, which means better performance. Because branch statements most often repeat themselves, it remembers recent branch results to make its predictions:
  • It has a cache of the last 64 branches that it has taken, and any time it sees one of these branches again it will immediately predict to the same branch destination. This technique, called dynamic branch prediction, is used on the Pentium and other processors with great results.

  • It keeps a history of all other branches and predicts based on the recent directions that branch took.
The cache technique has the advantage of being very fast. When the 604 fetches an instruction, it also sends the instruction's address to the branch cache. If the instruction is a recently executed branch, the cache will return the address of where the branch last went. This is immediately used to fetch the next instruction. Because this all occurs during the fetch of the branch instruction itself, there's no delay in fetching the first predicted instruction.

For conditional branches that aren't in the branch cache, the 604 keeps a history of recent times it saw that instruction. It keeps 512 such histories, each two bits wide, to remember whether the branch was taken during the last few executions. The processor hashes the instruction address to keep the branch histories distinct, and hash collisions are very rare.

Each history is set to one of four states: strongly taken, taken, not taken, and strongly not taken. The current state determines the branch prediction as taken or not taken. After the branch commits, the state is updated. Each update adjusts the state one step toward strongly taken or strongly not taken. The two intermediate steps are a hedge so that it will usually take two mistakes before a prediction changes. Because branches tend to repeat, this algorithm generally results in the following prediction:

  • If the branch was taken during the last two executions, the 604 predicts it will again be taken.

  • If the branch wasn't taken during both of the last two executions, the 604 predicts it again won't be taken.
Also with the 604, branches on the count register base their prediction on the current count value. This will usually predict loops correctly and yield good performance, since loops count down for a number of iterations before the final iteration causes an incorrect prediction.

But these techniques also come with a tradeoff: the 604 has an extra pipeline stage to dispatch instructions. This means instructions take longer to get through the pipe, and mispredicted branches are more expensive.

ARIES RISING

The 604 is the fastest PowerPC processor yet, and I can't talk about it here without also going into why it's such a fast engine. Besides its advanced branch prediction hardware, it has significantly more integer and floating-point hardware, which yields improved overall performance. Given that it's produced with a more advanced silicon process than the original 601, it's clocked above 80 MHz and offers blazingly fast computation for your code.

As a backbone for the chip, the instruction issuing and control logic allow the 604 to issue up to four instructions per clock, compared to the 601's and 603's effective three. As mentioned above, however, its pipeline has one extra decode stage and branches are issued and handled in their own branch unit. To help it speculatively execute more instructions than the other chips, it also comes with twice the number of "rename" registers than the 603. Twelve extra general-purpose and eight extra floating-point registers are available to hold speculatively produced results until a branch commits. The 604 is also the first PowerPC processor that can speculatively execute two branches at once. This, combined with advanced branch prediction, should keep the processor screaming even through complex code flow.

What most people will notice, however, is the additional integer math performance on the 604. At any one time, the 604 can have two add-subtract instructions and one multiply-divide instruction completing in a cycle. IBM says that it therefore has three integer units, but the multiply-divide hardware is also used for logical and bit manipulation operations. The bottom line is much better integer performance than the Power Macintosh 8100/80. As an example of this, the following code should execute nearly twice as fast on the 604 than on the 601:

do {
   unsigned long   datapoint;
   datapoint = *(dataarray + datasize);
   if (datapoint > kThreshold) {
      if (datapoint > kMaxLong - accumulate)
         MyOverflowError();
      accumulate += datapoint;
      samplecount += 1;
      }
   } while (datasize--);
Looking at this code, we see a few integer operations that will be dual-issued on the 604. As long as the datapoint values aren't too erratic, the 604 will better predict the first if statement's branch: it will assume that the current datapoint is on the same side of the threshold as on the previous iteration, which in fact is where it will tend to be. And the second if statement, which checks for an overflow, will (barring an exception) get predicted correctly out of the loop. The 601 or 603 may predict it incorrectly. So even though one integer unit will be busy doing the math, the overflow checking will effectively occur without stalling the pipeline.

The floating-point hardware was also supercharged. On the 601 and 603 processors, a single-precision floating-point instruction can issue and complete each cycle, but double-precision numbers take twice as long. The 604 allows one full double-precision multiply-add instruction to be issued and one to complete each cycle. The chip is twice as fast as the 601 and 603 for these double-precision calculations.

THE FUTURE IS IN THE STARS

So can Power Macintosh tell your future? It certainly tries to with the prediction techniques described above, and in doing so yields better performance. With the simple methods of the 601 and 603, or the dynamic prediction of the 604, your Power Macintosh will speculatively execute your code with seemingly psychic results.

What about the future of the Power Macintosh? The PowerPC architecture allows excellent growth. When I saw the specifications for the first processor, the 601, I was very impressed. It's an excellent design and it has proven to be a potent engine for the Macintosh. When I saw the specifications for the follow-on chips, however, I was really blown away. The 603 and 604 offer incredible performance for the price, and prove that the PowerPC architecture scales well both into low-cost/low-energy solutions and to the cutting edge in performance. And the technology applied to the 604 can be expanded in future chips, adding more execution units and advanced caches at higher clock speeds. The latest IBM POWER2 processors can issue two load/store, two logic/branch, two floating-point, and two integer instructions per cycle. These processors point to the future of PowerPC performance.

So without any additional tuning on your part, PowerPC will continue to improve your performance in the future. I also feel compelled to reiterate this advice from my previous columns: tune your critical code. Tuning often trades performance for code readability and maintainability, so carefully choose which code to tune and use code profilers (and the stars?) to guide your way.

DAVE EVANS (Aquarius, January 20-February 18) Look for opportunities to communicate. You are bound to have fun. Love is in the air; don't work too much or you'll miss it. Apple continues to hold promise for you. Compatible with Sagittarius.

Thanks to Phil Sohn, Peter Steinauer, and Eric Traut for reviewing this column.

This page was last modified on Sunday, April 06 1997 04:24
 

Community Search:
MacTech Search:

Software Updates via MacUpdate

Latest Forum Discussions

See All

Six fantastic ways to spend National Vid...
As if anyone needed an excuse to play games today, I am about to give you one: it is National Video Games Day. A day for us to play games, like we no doubt do every day. Let’s not look a gift horse in the mouth. Instead, feast your eyes on this... | Read more »
Old School RuneScape players turn out in...
The sheer leap in technological advancements in our lifetime has been mind-blowing. We went from Commodore 64s to VR glasses in what feels like a heartbeat, but more importantly, the internet. It can be a dark mess, but it also brought hundreds of... | Read more »
Today's Best Mobile Game Discounts...
Every day, we pick out a curated list of the best mobile discounts on the App Store and post them here. This list won't be comprehensive, but it every game on it is recommended. Feel free to check out the coverage we did on them in the links below... | Read more »
Nintendo and The Pokémon Company's...
Unless you have been living under a rock, you know that Nintendo has been locked in an epic battle with Pocketpair, creator of the obvious Pokémon rip-off Palworld. Nintendo often resorts to legal retaliation at the drop of a hat, but it seems this... | Read more »
Apple exclusive mobile games don’t make...
If you are a gamer on phones, no doubt you have been as distressed as I am on one huge sticking point: exclusivity. For years, Xbox and PlayStation have done battle, and before this was the Sega Genesis and the Nintendo NES. On console, it makes... | Read more »
Regionally exclusive events make no sens...
Last week, over on our sister site AppSpy, I babbled excitedly about the Pokémon GO Safari Days event. You can get nine Eevees with an explorer hat per day. Or, can you? Specifically, you, reader. Do you have the time or funds to possibly fly for... | Read more »
As Jon Bellamy defends his choice to can...
Back in March, Jagex announced the appointment of a new CEO, Jon Bellamy. Mr Bellamy then decided to almost immediately paint a huge target on his back by cancelling the Runescapes Pride event. This led to widespread condemnation about his perceived... | Read more »
Marvel Contest of Champions adds two mor...
When I saw the latest two Marvel Contest of Champions characters, I scoffed. Mr Knight and Silver Samurai, thought I, they are running out of good choices. Then I realised no, I was being far too cynical. This is one of the things that games do best... | Read more »
Grass is green, and water is wet: Pokémo...
It must be a day that ends in Y, because Pokémon Trading Card Game Pocket has kicked off its Zoroark Drop Event. Here you can get a promo version of another card, and look forward to the next Wonder Pick Event and the next Mass Outbreak that will be... | Read more »
Enter the Gungeon review
It took me a minute to get around to reviewing this game for a couple of very good reasons. The first is that Enter the Gungeon's style of roguelike bullet-hell action is teetering on the edge of being straight-up malicious, which made getting... | Read more »

Price Scanner via MacPrices.net

Take $150 off every Apple 11-inch M3 iPad Air
Amazon is offering a $150 discount on 11-inch M3 WiFi iPad Airs right now. Shipping is free: – 11″ 128GB M3 WiFi iPad Air: $449, $150 off – 11″ 256GB M3 WiFi iPad Air: $549, $150 off – 11″ 512GB M3... Read more
Apple iPad minis back on sale for $100 off MS...
Amazon is offering $100 discounts (up to 20% off) on Apple’s newest 2024 WiFi iPad minis, each with free shipping. These are the lowest prices available for new minis among the Apple retailers we... Read more
Apple’s 16-inch M4 Max MacBook Pros are on sa...
Amazon has 16-inch M4 Max MacBook Pros (Silver and Black colors) on sale for up to $410 off Apple’s MSRP right now. Shipping is free. Be sure to select Amazon as the seller, rather than a third-party... Read more
Red Pocket Mobile is offering a $150 rebate o...
Red Pocket Mobile has new Apple iPhone 17’s on sale for $150 off MSRP when you switch and open up a new line of service. Red Pocket Mobile is a nationwide MVNO using all the major wireless carrier... Read more
Switch to Verizon, and get any iPhone 16 for...
With yesterday’s introduction of the new iPhone 17 models, Verizon responded by running “on us” promos across much of the iPhone 16 lineup: iPhone 16 and 16 Plus show as $0/mo for 36 months with bill... Read more
Here is a summary of the new features in Appl...
Apple’s September 2025 event introduced major updates across its most popular product lines, focusing on health, performance, and design breakthroughs. The AirPods Pro 3 now feature best-in-class... Read more
Apple’s Smartphone Lineup Could Use A Touch o...
COMMENTARY – Whatever happened to the old adage, “less is more”? Apple’s smartphone lineup. — which is due for its annual refresh either this month or next (possibly at an Apple Event on September 9... Read more
Take $50 off every 11th-generation A16 WiFi i...
Amazon has Apple’s 11th-generation A16 WiFi iPads in stock on sale for $50 off MSRP right now. Shipping is free: – 11″ 11th-generation 128GB WiFi iPads: $299 $50 off MSRP – 11″ 11th-generation 256GB... Read more
Sunday Sale: 14-inch M4 MacBook Pros for up t...
Don’t pay full price! Amazon has Apple’s 14-inch M4 MacBook Pros (Silver and Black colors) on sale for up to $220 off MSRP right now. Shipping is free. Be sure to select Amazon as the seller, rather... Read more
Mac mini with M4 Pro CPU back on sale for $12...
B&H Photo has Apple’s Mac mini with the M4 Pro CPU back on sale for $1259, $140 off MSRP. B&H offers free 1-2 day shipping to most US addresses: – Mac mini M4 Pro CPU (24GB/512GB): $1259, $... Read more

Jobs Board

All contents are Copyright 1984-2011 by Xplain Corporation. All rights reserved. Theme designed by Icreon.